Should I plea guilty to something I didn;t do even if my lawyer tells me to.?

Question

I didn't do anything wrong except try to help my nephew out with a place to stay and he got a bunch of charges on him and I got throwed in the middle but haven't don't anything wrong , I don't wanna plea darn it I didn't do anything. Does anyone have any advice ? Looking forward to hearing form some of you and really worried.Tami

Answer 1

Lots of lawyers accept plea deals to dispose of little cases so they can move on to other things.

Ask the lawyer to explain the charges against you very clearly, in layman's terms. And if you still feel that you have not committed any crime, then ask the court to appoint you a new lawyer.

Are you charged with harboring a criminal, or as an accessory?

Answer 2

OK, Tami I will try this again. I have had some experience with this. In speaking with people who were in jail fighting criminal cases, I was told that as time goes on most of the time the D.A. drops charges. Just to get you to take a deal. Taking a deal is an admission of guilt. Remember the no one is going to serve time for you not even the person you helped. If you decide to accept a deal you will always have a criminal background. This may prevent you from pursuing some career choices, or even obtaining some relatively low-level jobs. Not to mention some universities with not let you enroll if you have a criminal background. Saying you did something that you did not do can amount to a very difficult life after you make that decision. If you did nothing than FIGHT, FIGHT TILL THE END! Remember this is your life not any one else's. You have a right to let twelve other people judge your actions. All they have to have is reasonable doubt and the have to let you go.
Again I say Fight.

Answer 3

This may sound silly, but sometimes it is better to listen to the lawyer and plead guilty. We all know that the legal system has a huge backlog of cases that cannot get through, and to add fire to the fuel, pleading guilty may get you off more easily than if you hadn't. For example, there are cases when people refused to plead guilty to 2nd degree murder and received a conviction of capital murder and the death penalty.

Answer 4

You didn't do any thing wrong is your personal view. In th eye of law you might be wrong. Your lawyer considering all the aspects would have suggested you to plead guilty. Even other wise as a citizen of the country there is nothing wrong you plead guilty and correct yourself.

Answer 5

if your lawyer is advising you to plead guilty i can oly assume he thins they have sufficient eveidence that u will be found guilty anyway, therefore if u plead guilty to start with you are likely to recieve a lesser punishment. I am not a lawyer but had a smiliar experience, i plead guilty and got the minimum punishment available, which is what i wanted, in the end the choise has to be yours and your lawyer should be explicitly explaining why he wants u to choose this course of action

Answer 6

What became your age while charged? the place you tried as an person or as a minor? EDIT nicely your possibilities of taking back the plea settlement are next to 0. It won't happen till you coach you have been below duress (like being tortured or threatened with a gun). You have been an person and you have refused the deal or request a clean criminal expert. yet truthfully you possibilities of triumphing could have been very very slender till your pal could have been prepared to take each and all the blame by using attesting which you had no longer something to do with the crime. in portion of fact that by using staying in the door doing no longer something on an identical time as your pal went psycho that made you look such as you have been making specific no one bypass the door. you're able to have run and phone police to end your pal, which could have given you particularly some credibility. all the different belongings you stated are irrelevant: lie detectors are actually not admissible in court docket (they are actually not good); putting you on the stand could have been a mistake, the prosecutor could have overwhelmed your testimony twisting your words and making you look very undesirable. What your criminal expert did became to keep you from going to reformatory, and you're able to see it from that standpoint. His job is to no longer have confidence you, his job is to grant you the main suitable feasible advice, is up you to take it or no longer. And based on the fees you have been very fortunate to no longer be required to accomplish a little reformatory time. And returned, Courts in no way in no way in no way take back a "voluntary" plea settlement; as quickly as you sign it incredibly is accomplished. Your strategies are 0. EDIT by using the way steer away from making racial comments like once you suggested: "...why did no longer I end a 300 lb BLACK guy from threatening somebody..." His race is irrelevant to your argument: he became risky for being "3 hundred lb" and by using having a knife; he being "black" it incredibly is irrelevant.

Answer 7

cant really answer this without knowing what you are being offered ans what you would be charged with.

Look at the difference in sentancing for each charge and decide if you can deal with it if convicted. Your attorney should be upfront with you about your chances. Get another opinion from another attorney.

Answer 8

First advice, be honest with yourself. When you say you "helped someone get into a place", did you help them trespass?

What exactly are the charges against you?

If you actually are innocent, fire your attorney and get a better one who will actually defend you.

Answer 9

red is the only guilty man at shawshank. if you plead you will do less time for the crime you really did committ but haven't been arested for. you know what i'm talking about!!

Answer 10

If you aren't guilty of anyting - then don't plead guilty. It is as simple as that.