13th amendment violation?

Question

Should the draft be outlawed in violation of the 13th amendment(abolished slavery and involuntary servitude)? I know the supreme court ruled it Constitutional(can i get a link or more info on that?), but should they have? Why or why not?

Answer 1

Because, unlike slavery, military service is a service to the country that is the duty of every able bodied man (and women, come to think of it) that is a citizen.

Answer 2

Link to court cases and dicta relating to the 13th Amendment and the Draft:
http://www.usconstitution.net/consttop_drft.html

The simple fact is that the Government makes us do stuff all the time, stuff that we don't want to do -- from being drafted to the military to spending time on a jury to doing our taxes -- and the framers of the 13th Amendment did NOT intend for people to be relieved from civic duties when it released people from being slaves to other humans (and the equivalent of property).

And, up until the 20th Century, we simply needed a draft for self-protection. Our country would not have existed without it.

Answer 3

No when you filed with civil service when you were young, you gave the government the right to draft you

Answer 4

If you are drafted and you don't want to enter the service, just go to Canada or Russia or Europe. Hey I hear Afganistan is looking for some more suicide bombers, go sign up for that one. :)

Answer 5

i trust that the authorities does have the right to point that you enlist if the rustic's protection is in chance. for example In international conflict 2 and the Civil conflict united statesa. protection became in chance via powers attempting to spoil them. The Germans and the jap needed international domination and the South needed to be its personal u . s .. i come upon that they ought to purely be able to draft human beings into the defense force on condition that the rustic's chance is at stake. If unlike our situation in Iraq, then it really is going to purely be voluntary like that's been because WW2. it really is bigoted that wealthy youthful ones do not ought to serve yet a number of them do finally end up enlisting via them being so patriotic. i visit also see why human beings do not choose their youthful ones going to conflict. a million. those who flow to conflict come back as diverse human beings. they arrive back with reviews few human beings ever see of their lifetimes. those may nicely be very scarring ona man or woman and may change them continuously. mum and dad prefer to work out their youthful ones smile and chuckle. those who come back from conflict do not. 2. lack of existence. mum and dad do not choose their flesh and blood that they prefer to lack of existence to die in conflict. they prefer their children to proceed to exist them and characteristic good lives. 3. Wounds/injuries. human beings may nicely be severly damage in conflict and that adjustments a persons' lifesyle continuously. my father for example became in Operation Iraqi Freedom and jumped out of a airplane. His parachute didnt open and he fell right down to earth and landed adversarial to the percentages right into a container of dug up and loose airborne dirt and mud and broke countless the bones in his body. he will ever be able to get better type his injuries and suffers from his disablement daily. He desires he didnt get damage yet is chuffed that he went to wrestle for his u . s .. My father isnt an same as he became once and he not in any respect will be yet he dosnt be apologetic about his patriotic accountability to the US military. There you flow. -Kirk

Answer 6

Slaves - didn't get paid

Draftees - do

Don't like it, leave. Slaves couldn't do that.

Are you Liberals REALLY this dumb, or are you just pretending?

Answer 7

that's a good point... i'll mention if they come for me...