Greatest QB Ever?

Question

Who is the greatest qb in NFL History?

And give me a REAL reason, “he’s the best” isn’t a reason

Answer 1

Unitas, the brought alive the forward pass..

Answer 2

First of all, Stephen QB's don't win a RING without a good TEAM!
QB's should NEVER be based on how many championships they have. QB Jason Garret has 3 rings, Marino, Steve Young and Brett Favre have 2 combined.

Dan Marino owns every significant QB record and he did this with absolutely NO THREAT of a running game. If Marino was on those 1980's 49er teams he may have won 7 championships.
Dan Marino is the best ever.

Answer 3

Brett Favre! Here are the reasons..
1. These are the records he is within the reach of breaking..
Most Passing Yards
Most Passing Attempts
Most Wins by Starting QB
2. These are the records he already has..
Most Consecutive Starts (QB)
Most 3,000 yard passing season (15)
Most Consecutive 3,000 yard passing season (15)
Most Pass Completions: 5,021
Most Seasons with 30-plus TD passes:8
Most Consecutive Games with TD pass, postseason: 16
Most NFL MVP awards
3. He's an amazing person, he's human just like me and you. Struggled with a drug addiction, lost loved ones, dealt with cancer in his family..
4. This one also has to deal with #3, he played the day after his father died against the Oakland Raiders. One of his best performances...EVER! 399 passing yards and 4 TD passes.. 4 yards shy of his best ever record.. leading his team to a 41-7 win.
5. He loves the game... how many people will come back year after year after year to play the game.
6. He's humble, you will never hear him boast. He once said, "I'm not in it for the records, they just come along with playing the game I love."

Personally, I think he's the greatest, not for all the records, but because he's one of the best role models out there. He's called the Grid Ironman for a reason. Take into an account that all those records have been achieved throughout some of the worst recieving crews that the Packers have ever had. Call him a gun-slinger or whatever, but he's football when it was football. Not the pansy crap game that's played today. He plays it with the mentality of two teams, one goal.
Hope this helped

Answer 4

Otto Grahm - Cleveland Browns

Not one Quarterback won more championships.. He and Paul Brown coaching dominated the NFL from the day he started playing to the day he retired. I don't care that it was before Super Bowls because that was the same thing as a Super Bowl back then, the only difference is the media hype over a Super Bowl. It was still the NFL and it was still impressive. OTTO GRAHM!!! And this coming from a die hard Houston fan. I coulda said Warren Moon but he never accomplished what Otto did.

Answer 5

properly, in case you're conversing approximately actual now, then the consensus winner(s) for the suitable QB ever might the two be Joe Montana or Johnny Unitas. Frank Tarkenton, John Elway, and Steve youthful are additionally in some cases seen as QBs interior the precise tier to boot. yet, in terms of Brett Favre, i think of he would be prepare with the 2nd record of QBs I named with Tarkenton, Elway, and youthful. he's a huge QB, has a great and long occupation, and has certainly particularly more desirable with age. the main significant clarification why i do no longer see him transforming into the "superb QB ever" is as a results of fact he has basically gained one million great Bowl. Now, i've got faith that the suitable QB ever would be Peyton Manning. yet, he has basically gained one million great Bowl actual? properly, i think of he is going to end his occupation with 2 or 3, and could play into his 40s like Favre. Manning is extra effective than Favre, and that i've got faith will continually be interior the communicate of being the suitable QB ever. additionally observe how i did no longer record Marino previously. it relatively is as a results of fact Marino is almost in between the two lists. He became in no way statistically solid as Montana or Unitas, yet having a fifteen-0 checklist would not harm your resume, actual?

Answer 6

Brett Favre. He plays the game for the joy of playing. He will likely hold every major passing record after this year. If Favre was QB of Indy they would have won the super bowl a lot sooner. The reason the Pack have not been going far is because he can't do it all by himself, nobody can.

Answer 7

Brett Favre. It's hard for me to say as a Bears fan, but he did win a Super Bowl, he has one of the best QB ratings of all time, he's probably gonna break all of Dan Marino's records next year, he's the only 3 time MVP (95, 96, 97).

Answer 8

I honestly can't really tell about retired QBs. I read a lot about them, watched some re-runs, but never followed them the whole season while they played, since I was too young.

...but here's some analysis...
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/35424/top_five_nfl_quarterbacks_of_alltime.html

I asked my bf about Joe Montana, and he said that he was the scariest one with Jerry Rice. They were pretty much unstoppable. He was a Rams fan when they were the L.A Rams, and he never watched a Rams vs 49ers game because he hated to see the Rams losing "again."

edit//...actually, I think I change my opinion about Joe Montana. He had a great team around him. He did nothing when he went to the Chiefs. He lost his team and he went downwards...I guess Dan Marino is the best of all time....

Answer 9

Troy Aikman. Most accurate passer ever. Took the down-and-out Cowboys from a 1-15 season to THREE Super Bowls in the 90s. Great leader and humble and not "showy" like so many professional athletes are today.

Answer 10

well its very hard to compare the retired with the ones playing now only because their career has not ended and they can go up or downhill from now.

with that said

i think peyton manning will prove to be the best when his career is over. he has a very long time left and will only improve.he is very good at remembering plays and leading his teammates. he is a team leader. he pumps them up and makes sure that if something goes wrong that it will be fixed.

he was raised with football in his blood. he is in a football family.
all 4 famous qbs.

i think peyton has alot ahead and winning this Superbowl was only the beginning of everything

Answer 11

While I personally prefer Joe Montana or Dan Marino, I can make a case for John Elway easier than I can for either of the other greats.

Elway is the all-time leader in come-from-behind victories, and he engineered many of them without an all-star squad around him.