Is Vince Young the best rookie quarterback, and how far can he take the Titans?

Question

Playoffs? AFC Campionship? Superbowl? Maybe, Peyton did it.

Answer 1

Vince may have been the most exciting QB this year but he cannot dominate and win games all by himself. Remember Peyton has a hall of fame WR (Marvin Harrison), strong rookie runner (Addai) and a second WR who is a legit all-pro, Wayne. PLus the defense came alive in the playoffs. Remember the Colts only scored 15 points in the win over the Ravens -- credit the D and Vinatieri with that win.

Young can return the Titans to the playoffs. But to win a playoff game, he'll need help so that the other teams don't focus squarely on him. Remember the Pats limited LT and knocked out the Chargers.

Answer 2

Well, I believe there is a strong possibility that Vince Young will return to the Titans. The reason why is because Young was supposed to be the future of the franchise. The only reason why he isn't in there now is because he was going through some personal difficulties and he was not able to assume the responsibilities at the time. So they went with Kerry. But since then Kerry hasn't made any mistakes. But the key here, is that Collins is not in his 20's or early 30's. He is in his late 30's which means that his production is likely to level off in another year or 2. The Titans need to keep Young because he did show some promise in his earlier seasons. I think they will because it is so hard to find a good QB. Young isn't a bad QB, he just let the pressures of life get to him which caused him to lose his job to Collins and lose the locker room. The only way that the Titans get rid of Young is if he asks for a trade or release, or they pick up another QB in the draft or free agency. But Collins is in there because he is playing well. The moment Collins starts wavering, then you may hear talk of Young coming back.

Answer 3

Peyton actually had receivers though. Vince young is the best qb right now but I think that one of the others could catch up to him. I hate Matt Leinart but I think eventually he will be the best rookie quarterback of his class with Jay Cutler a close second. It all comes down to playing style and I just think that defenses will figure him out. They might win the wild card next year but he is playing in a very tough AFC.

Answer 4

The best? That is debatable. I thought Cutler and Leinart also looked very good. How far can Young take the Titans? By himself, not far. That is why in the long run I think Cutler, in particular, is part of a much better team and will do more to get his team to the SB than Young ever will.

Answer 5

1)Leinart is a better Quarterback than VY.
2)Vince Young's play was less than impressive, and once teams play him like they play Vick he won't do much.
3)They'll compete for a wild card and may make the play-offs, but they will be defeated by a team with a strong defense(like the Ravens or Chargers) that has the speed to deal with VY and the ability to clamp down on Travis Henry.

Answer 6

Vince Young is a pure stud and easily the best rookie QB.

I believe he can take his team to the Super Bowl eventually, but has ALOT to work on.

If you look at his W's this year, most were against mediocre teams and he barely pulled them off. Expect a 7 win season next year.

Answer 7

Teams are going to figure Vince Young out. Coming in midway through the season teams didn't have a whole lot of info on him.

Answer 8

He's a pretty good rookie quarterback and I think he'll take them to the AFC Champinship game

Answer 9

Yes he is, and probably to the wild-card round of the playoffs.

HH -- how did the Pats limit LT? He had 123 rush yards, 64 rec yards, and 2TD. You call that limiting? We only rushed him 23 times too. Had we actually been more conservative and ran more, he would have racked up even more yards. The Chargers beat themselves with stupid mistakes, the Patriots did not beat us.

Answer 10

Yes, absolutly. Next year, they might hit playoffs, but the year after, they will be hot, AFC Championship