Do you believe in physically disciplining children? Why or why not?

Question

Personally, I don't. When I was growing up, spanking was the primary disciplinary method, and it didn't make me follow the rules, it made me subvert them.

Answer 1

The thing with physical discipline is that it is too hard to separate a parent's frustration from the act itself. Often physical discipline becomes a means of parents being upset with the children and those feelings can be intensified by other influences like stres, over-tiredness, anxiety, or being mad at your spouse. I grew up with physical discipline as well and I think there are situations in which I might use it, like if my child is doing something dangerous. I think it is important for parents to think first about whether the discipline is appropriate, in all forms of discipline and make sure that they are not hitting the child becasue it feels good instead of modifying behavior. That's pretty difficult to do, which is why I don't think physical discipline is a good way to discipline. Studies also show that it is generally not as effective as other forms of discipline, probably becasue it tends to be rash instead of well thought out and therefore it is inconsistent.

Answer 2

I too was spanked as a child which only made me want to rebel against the law. Today as a man who has children I see the mistakes of our parents. There are many different ways we can discipline of kids besides spanking them. I think when adults get upset with children and hit them then we are only setting an example to let the child know it;s ok to be angry. Don't get me wrong though. I am a black father with a black wife. We both agree that there is a time you must gain respect not fear but respect from you children.

Answer 3

A stability is critical. too a lot, and they get resistant to it or you get abusive. Too little discipline, and they get wildly uncontrolled. Making your expectancies sparkling in improve, and reacting in a fashion which they could foretell, makes it more convenient for them to modify their habit so that you pick to discipline a lot less. ensure they comprehend what your regulations are, and what the outcomes will be. clone of a cop, each and every from time to time you promises them a "caution" and frequently a stiffer outcomes like a superb is critical to get their interest, and then there are those repeat offenders that insist on doing penal complex time. As a figure you should regulate to the fellow newborn's needs. right it truly is the humorous ingredient: As a tutor of adlescent delinquents, i have frequently stood offensive youngsters in vacation, status on excellent of a step stool without room for transferring round, even as I lectured them about their habit till i develop into content textile with their body of recommendations and responses, which frequently took a lengthy, lengthy, lengthy time period. persistently, i have had many grant to enable me beat their bottoms as a couple of minutes of actual soreness can be a strategies a lot less torturous than a hour or extra of body of recommendations adjustment with required respectful solutions in the course of the on-going lecture the position they had to really admit that what they'd carried out develop into incorrect, ask for forgiveness, and grant to make ammends in repayment for what develop into carried out. For some little ones a swat on the butt is carried out and over with so instantly that that is only too truly forgotten, even as an finished evening status on a step stool explaining why they ought to have carried out some thing, what they ought to have carried out somewhat, and what they'll do to make up for it now, is a strategies extra academic.

Answer 4

Yes. It's the amount and method I disagree with. You can spank a child without leaving marks on him and practically beating him to death. He will usually get the point.

Answer 5

No, I believe in time out and depriving kids of something they want to do-tv, video games, going to the park, etc. Yes, spanking was in for me also, but I only got a smack on the bottom once.

Answer 6

i belive in parents being able to give a child a light slap to the legs or bum but this shouldnt cause physical harm, simply a shock to stop the childs behaviour.

only in extreme cases though.

Answer 7

I agree. With my daughter I used taking something away....a favorite game, etc. or not doing something we were going to do ( going to the zoo, etc. She learned. Violence breeds violence. Children who were beaten as a child become wife & child beaters.

Answer 8

When you build a smarter mouse trap, you breed a smarter rat?
@8-)