Psychoanalysis is a science - what do you think?

Question

Science is based on discernable and testable cause and effect relationships. Properly applied, psychoanalysis has proven that there are established causes and effects on a person's behaviour when subjected to different social, emotional and psychological stimuli. Because these affects have been documented, explored, and proven, because it is based on facts and theories, the realm of psychoanalysis falls under the realm of science.
Psychoanalysis is being abused by some psychoanalysts. But, these 'failures' of Freud's theories fail to detract from the positive application of what was and continues to be useful.

Answer 1

The therapudic relationship can be very beneficial but as a survivor of quite a few failed therapy attempts I know that it's very hard to establish good boundaries on both people's parts.I am now in a therapudic relationship that is safe and healing and has lasted for years.The only problem with classic analysis is that it takes a long time. But it took 38 years to become this damaged so I will work on healing for as long as it takes.

Answer 2

The biggest problem in regards to calling psychoanalysis a science is that Freud used case studies to back up this theories. While case studies are cool to read about and are good at showing us examples of illnesses, theories, etc., they are NOT empirical evidence. For something to be considered a science, empirical evidence (preferably in the form of longitudinal studies) must exist. Personally, I think Freud's work in ego defense mechanisms is genius, but no, I don't think psychoanalysis can be considered a science.

Answer 3

It's true that Psychoanalysis has proved effective. But, the issue is with insurance companies. Often they are only willing to pay for 6-8 sessions- maybe even less. Due to this, other effective methods that take a shorter time period to implement are dominating the counseling market. It's true that Psychoanalysis is effective, but it is true that others forms of counseling are as effective.