Should US citizens be deported?

Question

Should all Americans not of native American descent be deported back to their original homelands. They illegally stole the country and massacred the native people indiscriminately. This genocide was comparable to the genocides of Nazi Germany. Reparations should be given to native Americans and their land should be returned. Any memorials to the criminals responsible for this genocide such as General Custer should be removed. Any memorials to people involved in making propaganda movies glorifying this genocide such as John Wayne should have their memorials removed

Answer 1

dude, that is true! the government has been trying to deport all illegal immigrants, but they seem to forgot where they came from and what they did to native Americans. someone has to remember all that so they think twice before they say something.

Answer 2

>>>Should all Americans not of native American descent be deported back to their original homelands. They illegally stole the country and massacred the native people indiscriminately.>>>

Does that include black people like me as well?

>>>This genocide was comparable to the genocides of Nazi Germany.>>>

Comparing things to Nazi Germany is a popular exercise in overemotionalism. It also trivializes the real horror of the Holocaust.

>>>>Reparations should be given to native Americans>>>

How you gonna do that if you have all of us "deported"?

>>>and their land should be returned.>>>

Uh, news flash -- there's plenty of evidence that "native Americans" were not originally from America either.

Like white people, they too came to present-day America from somewhere else -- and killed the previous inhabitants in much the same way as you describe. Care to address that issue?

.

Answer 3

ONE IS TOO MANY! People like Michael disgust me. But when he or somebody he knows gets deported, then they'll speak up.

Answer 4

I'm a Native American... I am not a modern day tribal member, I am not even of North American tribal decent, I'm of Italian decent. My Grandmother was born in Italy, My Grandfather, Mother and Father were born in the U.S....all Native Americans. Indians, as you call them are not necessarily from North America, they are from South America, Asia, Alaska and so on. European historians thought people indigenous to the Americas were East Indians, thus the moniker "Indians"...Native Americans dislike this term Indians, so with that out of the way,...I don't live in the past, nor do I dwell on what was. People need to look toward the future and live in the present. How in the hell is anyone going to change things that happened way back when? It seems very unproductive to live life sniveling about what people did 100's of years ago. I think we would be better served to move forward using history to make positive changes. You ever notice how drunks and addicts dwell on the wrongs that others do? rise above the petty cry baby crap and think forward not backward.

" No matter where you go....There you are". live with it, if you don't like where you are, it's up to YOU to pack YOUR bags and find that little "paradise" YOU crave.. and don't crap in MY backyard!!!

Answer 5

then other citizens of countries around the globe need to be deported also. Since the beginning of time people have had their land taken away, other people have invaded, tribes moved. America is hardly the only country with this history. And you can put down the "white men" all you want, but you seem to enjoy using the technologies and luxuries provided by the thiefs. No offense, but while Europe was blossoming, the native Americans were no where near what we would call modern.

Answer 6

why do you ask question to which you already know the answer?
where do you deport the African Americans for instance or the whites that came from Britain? forget that and move on, if you are a native American then sorry for your predicament. American was destined to be what it is today, a home for the Europeans, Asians, Africans, etc, A home for all. American is a definition of a new world.

Answer 7

No, Your point is good food for thought though. Anyone not of native american descent has been placed here, uninvited by the original "rulers" of this country. It is all very unfair to them. But deportation would be a little extreme.

Answer 8

I get your point. There is a double standard here, but it always has been a double standard from the beginning of European reign. Double standards and amendments are just some tools that are used to maintain control. lies and deception are a couple more ways they keep control. However, sending people back to the place of their blood line is not going to happen simply because millions of people have no idea where they come from EXACTLY. Thanks to cross breeding and deception, finding ones roots will be difficult if not impossible for millions

Answer 9

Since I am about 6 different nationalities plus part Cherokee Indian, would I have the option to choose where I where would be deported to?

Answer 10

Although possibly just, yours is an impossible concept. We have made this land our own-- totally infested it and converted it for our use. We would have to do this voluntarily, and the majority agree, as well as all legislators. This will never happen. Maybe we should, but we of course won't.