who is sad that Hilary Duff and Joel Madden broke up???

Question

i am!

Answer 1

i am ! they were soo cute 2gether , i like Joel he cute n i like his music , gooo good charlotte ! who cares bout 5 yr diff ! i liked em alot , now he is w stupid nicole richie the twiggy

Answer 2

i am reallyyyyyyyy sad too !!!!!1
before i really love them and they were the best couple ever !
i thought they are never going to seperate but then...
now i am so angry at joel cause i think he was cheating on hilary and he leave her cause of nicole richie !
poor hilary duff. i am her crazy fan and i really love her. this is what she said on one interview, and that is why they broke up!
interview:
Sources close to both Hilary and Joel tell Star that reports claiming the pair’s age difference caused them to split is incorrect. In fact, it was Hilary who was the more mature one in the relationship. "They fought all the time about how immature he is and they really started drifting apart in recent months," a Duff source tells Star, adding it was she who ended the relationship. "He’s like a five-year-old, and she’s like a 45-year-old woman trapped in a teenager’s body. Hilary would say things to Joel like, ‘Why haven’t you grown up? We’ve been together for like two years and you just haven’t grown up. I have. I can’t believe how much I’ve changed, and you haven’t.’ It kept happening over and over, and she kept making those comments in recent months."

The Duff source adds that their respective lifestyles were at odds with each other: She’s a mature, Type A film actress — diametrically different than her partying nemesis and counterpart Lindsay Lohan — and he’s a laid-back rocker dude. "She’s filming movies with big movie stars, and she’s very career-oriented," the source says. "Not that Joel isn’t career-oriented, he’s just happy doing what he’s doing, being in Good Charlotte, and deejaying, while Hilary goes from movie to movie, magazine cover to magazine cover and from album to album. They just weren’t on the same page. They both were aware of the issues, so it was a pretty amicable split. They just grew apart."

The Duff source adds, "Their fights about him being immature were always about stupid things, that people in a relationship with that dynamic would fight about," the source says. "It would be stuff like about his punctuality, that he was late a lot when they met, and that he was irresponsible. There wasn’t one big bomb, like cheating. Toward the end, there was constant fighting, really over nothing. He wasn’t going out and partying and getting drunk all the time, or anything like that. In fact, he was very protective of her."

A Madden sources echoes that Hilary was the more mature partner in the relationship. "He’s the nicest kid, but she seemed like the older one, because she’s so much more mature," the source tells Star. "The split was kind of a surprise, because he is a good guy and they were very close. He’s not the type of guy who goes out to clubs and like hangs from chandeliers. He’s not a big drinker. He’s not that wild."

Answer 3

I am.I thought they made a good couple even though he was much older than her. In my opinion Joel and Nicole don't really fit but, maybe Joel is what Nicole needs to help her get better. To each its own I guess.

Answer 4

They were doomed from the start. She was like 16 or 17 when they started dating. She is and was too young to spend the rest of her life with one person. Plus most hollywood relationships don't last long.

Answer 5

I do but it looks like Joel's better for Nicole.. he made her eat!LOL!!

Answer 6

it was on tv and i saw it in the internet a couble of day a go

Answer 7

not me werent they like 5+ years apart? THats gross

Answer 8

Why are you sad? It's not like you actually know either of them...get a life!

Answer 9

Only you.

Answer 10

im just sad theyre still alive