if dhoni and kaarthik both are playing, then who should keep wickets?

Answer 1

first karthick was keeping his wickets well .but as he was out of the team ,he concentrated more on his batting skills.so taking into consideration the present situation he has to field n dhoni has to sit behind the stumps.

Answer 2

Dhoni

Answer 3

It is not a secret that Kssrthik is a better wicket- keeper than Dhoni but Dhoni has proved to be better with his bat and that's the reason Kaathik is a bench warmer. Since Dhoni is india's regular keeper the management won't disturb the arrangement at this point in time.

Answer 4

Dhoni is permanent in the team.
But that's not true about Kaarthik

When Kaarthik is not in the playing 11,Dhoni is the obvious
choice.
And when Kaarthik is in the playing 11,Dhoni will be the
first choice,Karthik shud keep wickets only if Dhoni needs rest
after a big innings or while playing against weak sides like
those who are not Test playing nations.

Answer 5

Dhoni.

Answer 6

Dhoni should keep wickets

Answer 7

Dhoni should keep wicket, as Karthik is an excellent fielder and will be more useful in the field.

Answer 8

kaarthik should be on the back of wickets.Kaarthik is expert than Dhoni and Dhoni should be given rest in the field because he plays massive shots which requires more energy.

Answer 9

Obviously Dhoni shud keep the wickets...coz he's a better wicket-keeper than Karthik

Answer 10

Both of their keeping is equal but Karthick has a better ground fielding so Dhoni shoul keep