Do you think Paula Abdul should be replaced in American Idol as a judge?

Question

In the paper it said that the American Idol people are saying that Paula Abdul might be replace next year as a judge on American Idol. They say it is her different personality. Would you replace her if you had a chance to?? Or would you want to replace another judge....and who would you replace them with??

Answer 1

That or let her broadcast from re-hab.

Answer 2

I personally don't like Paula, but I think the show would be weird without her. The show would be weird if any of the judges were gone, even though both Paula and Randy are worthless. Simon is the only good judge. It is funny to watch him and Paula get into fights, though! I would definitely miss that should she go!

Answer 3

YES!!!!!

It has nothing to do with the rumors floating around. I liked Paula Abdul as a performer. She is unable to form an opinion about any contestant's singing without first looking at Randy...just watch her on the show.

And when she goes give an comment about a contestant, it isn't anything that is constructive, it is always a generalization.

Answer 4

No especially since it was rumored that they wanted Courtney Love to be her replacement. I don't know about you, but I don't like the idea of someone who had her husband murdered and made it appear to be suicide, working for American Idol. Plus Paula likes to keep things on a positive note when possible.

Answer 5

Did you hear who may replace her? First it appeared to be Courtney Love (gasp) but now I hear it might be Whitney Houston. (gasp again).
I don't think it is wise considering her history and her susbstance abuse. I think it is way to soon and AI is in for alot of drama if they do replace her with Whitney. Then again maybe it would be good for ratings.
Personally (to answer your question) I think Paula may have had some drama lately but she is still doing her job well.
I would not know who should replace her.

PSA Courtney Love replacing her was just a rumor/joke. It isnt true. Thanks for small favors.lol

Answer 6

I think Paula Abdul is just another prop on that show like everything else. She keeps it interesting which is why they'll keep her on. The same reason they keep showing the horrible, talentless auditions. I can't honestly believe that after 6 seasons or however long the show has been on the air, that people after watching the show, still think that their voics sound good. I think it's all publicity and the show is a fake.

Answer 7

Paula has always been the most useless pile of crap on that show. They just stuck her on to be a set of boobs for the guys to look at. She has never offered any constructive criticism. She just pats everyone on the back and tells them, "great job". Her being a drunk is the most interesting thing she's ever done since the beginning of AI.

Answer 8

Yes, she always seems high or drunk which is not a good role model for all of the people who watch the show. Personally, I liked Jewel when she was a guest judge, a while back. She can see the talent, for being as young as she is. It would also put a younger judge into the mix.

Answer 9

I don't really like her that much, who would you replace her with. I think the need someone who is a singer and has had hits in the last 5 years.

Answer 10

I think she should be replaced by William Hung and he needs to sit in the same place, right beside Simon, since he was his favorite singer!!!!

Answer 11

The reason they want to replace her is that she's a mess hooked on prescription drugs. She's a liability and potential embarrassment.