Why should Israel and the United States even consider the Palestinians demand for a state?

Question

They have shown time and time again that they will not recognize Israel's right to exist, that they are only interested in being terrorist and have no propensity for peace.

http://csconservative.tripod.com/index.html

Seraphim - Actually there was never an independent state know as Palestine.

Answer 1

Palestinians should be pushed into the sea...kind of poetic justice, in my opinion.

Seraphim: when was "Palestine" a state? You should read a history book, my friend. It would have been had the armies of five "peaceful" Arab nations not invaded Israel on the day of her independence.

Answer 2

But the Palestinians recognized Israel,in the border before 1967,through the PLO,after the Oslo accord.Actually Israel said it was a mutual recognition:PLO recognized Israel's right to exist while Israel recognized PLO representing the Palestinian people.As for the Palestinian state that Israel promised them,well they are still waiting for it...And first of all it's Israel who should recognize the Palestinians right to exist...By not allowing millions of Palestinian refugees to come back to their land,Israel is denying their right to existence...So first Israel should recognize the Palestinians right to existence and then they could ask the Palestinians to recognize Israel,again...It's Israel who occupies Palestinian land...

Answer 3

i am going to't figure that out both. even as Israel develop into depending, it welcomed everyone there to live on as finished electorate, and many did. Arab Muslim and Arab Christian Israelis vote and carry public place of work, and performance each and each and every of the rights of citizenship. Arabic is truly one of Israel's professional languages. Is Lina announcing that Jews should be prohibited from determining to purchase land? Hmmm. Sounds only about apartheid to me. what percentage Jews are electorate of Gaza? Of Jordan? Are there any? i trust no longer. That sounds only about apartheid too.

Answer 4

Sadly, because we NEED oil. And our #1 supplier are the Arab states of OPEC and THEY promote the palestinian cause. Does anyone remember the 70s? Long lines at the gas pumps? OPEC slowed the flow of oil to the U.S. in part because Jimmy Carter gave formal recognition to Israel. The same fringe scientists that are now hawking (again -- they screamed about it then too) the global warming also said that the earth was running out of natural resources and that we'd all dry up (oil) within 20 years... Our national interests require us to give the nod to the Arabs and palestinians while we "Fully" support Israel's right to a peaceful existance. Personally, I think the so-called "palestinians" all need to go back to Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon, from where they originated.

Answer 5

Israel thinks the US does not have the right to exsist either.

September 10, 2001; School of Advanced Military Studies, Fort Levenworth.

Mossad, that is Israeli Intelligence, Ruthless and Cunning and has ability to attack US Forces.

Answer 6

Where do u live dude? US? Get US Congress to give Israel a piece of land for their new state in US, next to your house. Then you will understand how those conflicts started.

Answer 7

How easy it is to blame the teens who pelt stones onto the tankers and some other young lads who die for their country , and how easy it to call them terrorists ,

One of the biggest problems that world is facing is terrorism and the real terrorists , but one the veil will be unveiled and the real terrorists will come out to the world

Israel is not in their country now they are in a place that Palestine donated them because they have hearts , but the Israel started the problem , and at last some fools are arguing that it's Israels country ,

please go to history and learn what happened in middle east and Who is the real villain !!

Answer 8

we shouldnt.

The Taliban are starting to start a revolution in Pakistan now.

Osama is prolly going to use the pakistanise to attack Israel.

Hes also prolly going to convince people that America is the one whose to blame for Israel taking over their land.

We've got about 5 years till the Taliban take over...
we need to finish the Iraqi government + help destroy Iran's government so we can hand it to Iran's younger generation of capitalist people.

Turning and running from the middle east will eventually lead to mayhem, both in the middle east and in America.

the Taliban are taking over Palistan just like they took over Afghanistan. Setting up HQ to attack America and Israel once again.

We need Iran, Iraq, and Afghanistan's support to stop Osama and the Taliban once and for all.

Answer 9

59 years ago Palestine was a region and Israel didn't exist, but what's done is done. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict isn't a black and white issue. Both sides have caused injustice.

EDIT: I didn't realize that Palestine was only a region. Thank you for pointing that out to me. I used this opportunity to correct my mistake. Nonetheless, I believe it is unfair to criticize only Palestinians for the continuing conflict. Both Palestinians and Israelis are at fault for the perpetual violence, and the US is only fueling the violence by supplying Israel with arms and supporting Israels actions, no matter how deplorable.

Answer 10

Personally, I think once every five years on an appointed day, every one everywhere should up and move to another land, kinda like musical chairs. Borders are so silly.

Answer 11

Maybe, the question should be: Why shouldn't Israel be left to fight its own wa? After all, it always has shown itself to be a bully, not a victim.