Do you think that Isreal has the right to exsist?

Question

I don't. I think that the Jew's should have there own state though. It seems to me like no logic was involved in making the choice to give the Jew's land that already belonged to others. Trying to justify it by saying it is there home land doesn't do it for me. That's like another country deciding that "native americans" should get the U.S.A back. All the reasons for the jews to have a state in a different location are there, but anyone who thinks anything else besides "Isreal has the right to exist" is seen as evil. To me it makes most sense to give the Jew's part of Germany seeing as though the Germans are the ones who massacered them and made it that the Jew's needed thier own state. If not part of Germany, then part of Alaksa, one of the Hawain Islands, or some other state. Since Isreal's creation there has been nothing but violence and war in the middle east. Now, of course I don't support the violence or Iran on what seems to be there answer to the problem, but I can understand

the hatred the palastinians feel toward the Jews and America. I just truely cannot understand how people defend Isreal. Isreal is often aggressive and starts trouble and I can understand there need to be on the offensive but when the answer to all the violence and hatred is right in front of our eye's, idk...

... it is going to effect your country because the fuse of World War III has already been lit and when history looks back (if humans are still around and "civilized" after it) Isreal will have played a big part in starting it. More the U.S. though because we invaded Iraq.

The only reason Isreal has lasted is because of U.S. support. Without it, it surely would have fallen a long time ago, just like it did before.

Answer 1

To be honest, I do somewhat agree with you. There was no real reason to give the Jews land that was occupied by other people. I believe that that land should be given back to the Palestinians. They should be given land somewhere else. It would stop all of this conflict and war.

Answer 2

I think whoever can better assert themselves has the right to exist in this case. If the Palestinians form a cohesive group and attempt to expel the Jews that is cool. But for now they are backwards. They claim to have a common enemy but are unable to get past their own internal petty issues to either resolve their issues with the Jews or fight the Jews. So they lose because they are inept at this point in time.

Answer 3

Israel has the main appropriate to exist as long because it could carry it incredibly is territory. do they get help and help frm the U. S.? beneficial. And their enemies have been given help and help from different usa's too. verify your historic previous - Israel's defense force record is incredibly surprising. Israel is not any different than the different usa. It has a real to exist through fact no person has ben reliable sufficient to assert in any different case. playstation : You state that for the reason that Israel's advent there has been not something yet conflict and violence in the middle East. Are you implying that previous to Israel's advent there wasn't conflict and violence? Are you implying that if Israel ceased to exist the conflict and violence might supply up? i think of we can agree that the two a sort of statements are fake. it incredibly is recommended to verify the e book "The Case for Israel". i did not accept as true with each and all of the author's arguments, yet he makes some thrilling factors. ADDITION: I merely examine the different responses, and admittedly i think of everybody is out of line calling you a racist. you are able to debate the philisophical and ethical question of no count if it substitute into authentic for the international community to creat the _modern_ state of Israel in what had as quickly as been the Bristish Mandate of Palestine, without attacking the main appropriate of Jews as a human beings, or Judiasm as a faith, to exist. There look a super form of poorly concept out very own assaults right here, and for that I grant you my condolances.

Answer 4

It would be hard for me to hate and choose a picture for others.
Why can't palastne suggest to itself the world would be cooler if they didn't try to change the past so much.

Answer 5

If it doesn't happen in America I don't really worry about it, I concern myself with my nation only. YES I realize that is short sighted but I could not care less.

Answer 6

Just vote for Obama. He'll fix everything.

Answer 7

urm...Isreal isn't a state. it's a country