English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I am not saying that they are bad judges. They are actually pretty good at what they do on the show. But they are really quite average in thier own fields.

Name one great album or act that Simon has produced. Il Divo? Sorry, but NO!

Randy? What was he, a studio drummer for Journey, or something!?

And Paula Abdul? Okay, she's kinda cute. She can dance. But she never had any memorable work whatsoever!!!

But, like I said, they are really good at what they do on the show. They are pretty good critics, and very entertaining.

But don't you agree that they are (at best) average outside of the show?

2007-02-01 13:34:09 · 13 answers · asked by Zezo Zeze Zadfrack 1 in Entertainment & Music Music

13 answers

Randy actually played bass with Journey, but I agree with you. Then again, Simon only has to be good at being Simon in order to be entertaining.

2007-02-01 13:37:15 · answer #1 · answered by Omni D 5 · 1 0

properly enable's see... Mariah Carey - Her comments are not very useful, she hardly provides criticism, she talks way too a lot on each occasion she's commenting. Randy Jackson - he's getting previous. C'mon, adult adult males. you may not not say that you've not in any respect concept for only a chop up 2d that he's been on the educate for far too lengthy... Now days, his comments are not very depending and are often slightly off topic (e.x: at the same time as they commence speaking about trend) i ought to save Nicki because she says what's on her ideas, and she or he would not conceal it with 'darling, you understand i recognize you... yet...'. Yeah, ok. She gained't be the nicest decide, yet her comments are actual authentic! And yeah, her trend experience is slightly diverse than our 'generic', yet is that extremely contributing to her judging? No! the way she dresses is inappropriate. Keith, for me, ought to stay because he provides better effective comments than Mariah and Randy. he's straightforward.

2016-12-03 08:26:27 · answer #2 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

I've never seen the show. Never heard of Simon before the show started airing, heard about Randy a few times and remember some of Paula's stupid stuff but that's it. I don't subject myself to horse fodder if I can avoid it and that show as far as I am concerned is fodder.

2007-02-01 13:44:08 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

I agree with you .... Especially in regards to Simon and Randy.

I like Paul Addul (personally, not as a judge) ... but I wouldn't walk across the street on my day off to say hello to Simon or Randy.

2007-02-01 13:38:49 · answer #4 · answered by ValleyR 7 · 0 0

The only thing they are good at is being a distraction!
NONE of them are 'professional' anything!
I don't consider a 'bloke from England', a former drummer and former dancer PROFESSIONALS!
The program NEEDS music professionals (as judges) and those who know if a person has great stage presence.
I refuse to watch the program anymore because I CAN'T stand Simon. He is arrogant and knows NOTHING about music!

2007-02-01 13:46:58 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

It's all relative. Very few individuals become super famous for what they do. I bet you don't know who the best brain surgeon in the world is. Why is it you expect some players in the music industry to be world renowned? All three were, and are still very good at what they're doing, and they're making a hell of a lot of money in the process! That's not Mediocre in my book.

2007-02-01 13:48:15 · answer #6 · answered by unruhly429 2 · 0 0

Anyone could do what they do. I had never heard of Randy before, Paula is mediocre (though I like a few of her songs) and Simon has inflicted the likes of Robson and Jerome on us (I think). Nuff said.

2007-02-01 13:39:45 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

100% yes. Paticularly Simon

2007-02-01 13:39:12 · answer #8 · answered by ME 4 · 0 0

Ha ha, I heard that they are replacing Paula with Courtney Love...now I like some of her songs, but she can't sing worth a lick. Terrible choice, if that's true.

2007-02-01 13:37:16 · answer #9 · answered by CC 6 · 0 0

I personally think the show is over rated myself. I mean what artists have ever made it other then from the show it self.

2007-02-01 13:37:56 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers