Question about the ethics of capital punishment?

Question

Why are Catholics so gay in their opposition of the death penalty?

Answer 1

The death penalty makes us no better than the people we are punishing. If we would claim to be an enlightened society, there is no excuse for murder, institutionalised or otherwise.

From a purely logical point of view, the death penalty makes no sense anyway:

1) There is always the chance that somebody was wrongly convicted and sentenced. There are too many cases on record where somebody has faced the executioner, only to be exonorated later.

2) More and more evidence points to the probability that aggression, psychosis and all our other baseness is actually rooted in biology. For example, having studied criminals, they have found that there is a prevalence of Seratonin imbalance. Since sSeratonin is the chemical responsible for controlling mood and self control, and a shortage of seratonin has been linked to increased aggression and impairment of reasoning, the question has to be asked: isn't judging a psychopath the same as judging somebody with downs-syndrome or some other mental illness? Yes, the psychopath is dangerous and should be treated as such, but is it right to condemn him for what is essentially a birth defect, especially if you don't try to help him or her first?

So yeah, I might not agree with Catholics in particular and Christians in general on a number of issues, but in this we are on the same page.

Answer 2

First, it incredibly is not from now on a very good way of combating substantial crimes. homicide fees even tend to be greater advantageous in US states that use the dying penalty in comparison to those who do not. And the U. S. (the only industrialised usa that still makes use of capital punishment) has a a strategies greater advantageous homicide value than different to boot better international locations. to boot, no count if it have been powerful, a super form of human beings merchandise to the way it extremely is utilized. in case you may cope with to pay for a very good criminal expert, you isn't finished interior the U. S.. in case you kill a member of a racial minority (regardless of your individual race) it incredibly is statistically very now not probable that the prosecutor will additionally look for the dying penalty. additionally, extremely circumstances innocuous everybody seems to be finished. Mike, your argument assumes that persons commit homicide looking forward to to be caught and punished, and that they do now not suggestions through reality it incredibly is many years (spent in detention center) before the punishment is finished. it incredibly is ridiculous. very the super majority of murderers the two act without thinking the outcomes, or they assume to flee with it, wherein case it incredibly is not substantial what the punishment is thru the reality they gained't be caught. no person thinks "it extremely is okay to commit homicide, through reality it is going to probable be a together as before i'm finished."

Answer 3

Gay??? Catholics are wrong on a lot of issues like child molesting priests and birth control. Capital punishment should be used for all pedophiles no matter what.

Answer 4

I personally don't believe in the death penalty. I think that it is unjust and should be banned completely. I think that everyone wants revenge so bad that they are willing to kill for it. Two wrongs don't make a right.

Answer 5

ALL OF YOU ARE WRONG! CATHOLICS WOULD NOT HAVE A RELIGION WITHOUT THE DEATH PENALTY. HOW WAS JESUS KILLED? BY THE DEATH PENALTY. IF THE DEATH PENALTY HAD NOT EXISTED THEN THERE WOULD NOT BE ANY CRISTIAN FAITH WHAT SO EVER. EVERYONE WOULD BE JEWISH(WE ALL KNOW HOW FUN THAT WOULD BE).

Answer 6

I believe they are not gay about it. They just defend what they believe in like any other organization with a point of view. Just like Jews are all tragic because they are the "victims" of the world, and the Muslims are so passionate with beheading everyone, or simply exploding them. They are all defendors of their ideals. You might have a few ideals yourself. That doesn't mean you're gay or should be less respected by others. Including me. Have a nice day!!!!

Answer 7

WHat is funny, is the same people who hate liberals because they "kill" babies(abortion). These are the same people who are PRO-WAR and Pro-Death penalty. Shows you where they stand huh? PRO-LIFE! hahaha yups

Answer 8

Pro-life is being pro-life for the victim.

Answer 9

it's that God thing they have going. you know Jesus and his love one another stuff. and the part about God writing in stone "thou shall not kill". fanatic cult things.