Would you recommend a Bio wheel filter or a Whisper Power filter for an aquarium with just a few LIVE PLANTS?

Question

I know that a wet/dry filter would be best if you want a forest in your tank; I just want a few plants yet I'd like them to last so which power filter is best?

Answer 1

worry about your choice in plants instead of your filter. java fern or one of the anubias are great choices for starter plants. i have been getting really nice java fern in little tubes from petco they are labled "tropical fern" or something like that. avoid anything that should be a house plant. they have been popping up everywhere. "lucky bamboo" which isn't even a bamboo is a really bad choice unless you don't mind tossing it in a month or two. the stalks are durable but the sprouts get moldy. you don't want to introduce mold to your aquarium -- keep the houseplants out. you can root some houseplants in your aquarium but they won't grow underwater.

Answer 2

First of all, what size tank is this? You can efficiently filter a tank up to 30 gallons with a powerhead hooked up to a sponge filter intake... This is what I have been doing on my planted tanks for years with no problems...

Answer 3

It does not matter as both will have the same effect on plants, which is none at all. It is the CO2 content you have to watch for, so keep the water level as high as possible to reduce surface agitation and keep the CO2 from gassing off.

As far as which is a better filter overall, the bio-wheel is by far better. I have tried both and the difference between the 2 is huge.

Answer 4

you dont need a wet dry for a planted tank, the key is to keep it warm, make sure there is co2, and iron in the tank. i have a planted tank with a whisper and the tank does great, its has a yeast reactor and a heat matt under it.

Answer 5

Nope, you will not get to any extent further suitable filtration out of a bio-wheel. That wheel is an enforce to make up for the biggest flaw of putting filters - loss of media. in reality, i spotted fairly no overall performance distinction between the aquaclear putting filter out without bio-wheel and the emperor with one. Canister filters do not could placed self assurance in such issues - they're between the top forms of filtration through fact they seem to be a huge canister that could carry a ton of media. now and back - no, generally - basic is ultimate. this suggests not in basic terms is there room for a ton of micro organism, yet a ton of room to place something you prefer into it - peat moss to soften the water, overwhelmed coral to alkalize it, carbon to filter out impurities, ammonia substarte to handle spikes, filter out floss to polish the water - the versitality is leaps and limitations previous. i might additionally decide to characteristic that sticking bio-wheels can substitute right into a challenge. much less shifting components means much less can pass incorrect. For putting filters i p.c. Aquaclear through fact a) it does not have a bio-wheel to interrupt and b) it incredibly is in basic terms an open tank concept that holds greater media then different putting filters and so is greater versatile too. additionally, putting filters make up for their loss of media by pushing water greater promptly in the path of the filter out. The GPH mandatory isn't something which would be generalized. Canisters do a much greater powerful interest, meaning they don't desire as severe GPH to do the same interest. additionally GPH incredibly means not something - a one hundred gallon tank that has 10 pygmy gourami in it could actual function properly with a filter out for a 20 gallon tank. needless to say it fairly is stupid, despite if it incredibly is merely to make a factor. I even have used many forms of filters in the 22 years for the reason that my first tank, and have come to the factor the place i've got sworn off putting filters and now in basic terms use canisters and sponge filters. additionally, merely an ingredient word - in assessment to putting filters, canister filters draw the water up in the path of the media and then the water hits the impeller, whilst putting filters draw water up in the path of the impeller and into the media. for persons with sand, it fairly is the version between the sand scratching the impeller and not. talking of undemanding, an undemanding sponge filter out is between the main effective forms of filter out to boot. back, so basic that persons don't think it, despite if it incredibly is authentic.

Answer 6

I prefer the biowheel and feel that it is one of the best biological filters available.

Answer 7

some power filter are bio filters, so both