English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

There were 100s of Millions of people killed in the past during wars and occupations. Why was only the killings of Jews taken into account? Are not other peoples in the world are human beings?

There is not other way than any responsible human being denying the Holocaust as a Myth. Why dont you now... unless you are an EVIL...?

2007-01-29 19:04:50 · 10 answers · asked by anishraja100 2 in News & Events Current Events

10 answers

Congradulations on the double double posting posting of the same question question.

Here is the copy and paste of my answer to you:

So, you wish to dismiss the Holocaust as a hoax?

Want to know what kind of people do this? White Supremacists. You might be more comfortable at such a site as the Stormfronters. You would fit in very nicely with them. And... that is NOT a compliment.

I guess you can label me as EVIL because I happened to study the Holocaust out of my own interest and I KNOW it was real.

Now, history does tend to dismiss that other than Jews were killed. I take issue with that. There is no real estimate of the Gyspies (Rromani) who were killed because they were not, for the most part, even recorded in the books. The vast majority of Rromani could not write and were either recorded with a checkmark or not recorded at all.. The recorded guestimate is 500,000 but the more accurate estimate is well, and I mean well, over a million. Some guess as high as 5 million.

Gays, political dissidents, the mentally handicapped and anyone the Reich wanted out of the way also went.

The Holocaust was a mass excercise in genocide. You cannot compare it to any other war because of the scale and the method. These people were non-combatants, they were not involved in any part of any war. The Jews and the Gypsies were extinguished based soley upon ethnicity. There was no other reason for their deaths.

One of the things that was particularly atrocious was the method of death. Go read about the medical "experiments" in Theory and Practice of Hell (I provided a link to where you can get a copy). Did you know that Mengele actually had a special "Gypsy Family Camp" in Auschwitz? This was not a good thing. They were specifically used for "medical experiments".

Have you ever heard that those who ignore the past are doomed to repeat it? Look around little girl. It IS happening again, although not on the same scale as the Holocaust.

I defy you, little girl, to find some pictures from the Holocaust and look into the eyes of those people who looked like walking skeletons or look at the piles of emaciated corpses and not feel something. If you do not, I call YOU evil. If you dispute these exist, email me. I can provide quite a few sites with them.

Before you spew this stupidity and make yourself look like a complete idiot, you might want to do some reading. I am including links to a few good places to start.

2007-01-29 20:45:32 · answer #1 · answered by j 5 · 5 0

You are an idiot. The fact that the Third Reich engaged in the planned genocide known as the Holocaust has been historically established in hundreds of civil and criminal trials under American, British, French, Canadian, German and Israeli law for over a half century since the end of World War II. Anyone who claims the Holocaust never happened is either totally ignorant of history or has an agenda of hate against the Jews. Now which would you be I wonder?

2007-01-30 03:18:29 · answer #2 · answered by godeep 3 · 4 0

The Holocaust occured nust as did the Rape of Nanking and the Cultural Revolution and the Stalinist Purges and the Partition of India and the genocide in Darfur and Cambodia. No one id denying that other mass killings have occured in the 21st century. Also it was not only Jews killed during the Nazi Holocaust, but homosexuals, Gypsies (Roma), the handicapped and many others as well.

2007-01-30 03:15:21 · answer #3 · answered by Runa 7 · 1 0

In the Holocuast, Hitler did not just kill Jewish people-he killed gays, and those who supported the Jewish people. Those who helped the Jewish people hide in their homes, etc. Anyone who did not cooperate with Hitler were harmed. The reason it was so well documented for people to know about is because it was mainly due to the horrific treatment and deaths of one race-Jewish. Plus, if you see film footage, of the survivors, they were living skeletons. It was something people in other parts of the world including the USA, that heard of these horror stories, but didn't believe that such atrocities would be happening. Then when it was discovered how bad it was, that is when people took the action they did. If you were to read "Diary of Ann Frank" or hear a survivor speak about what they went thru-you would choose to realize it was true. Also, if it didn't happen, then why, to this day, around the concentration camps like Dauchua (sp?) and other camps where deaths of millions occurred, do no birds come around singing? It's in rememberance of what bad happened at those places-is why the birds don't sing in those areas. Plus, if you want to know of a modern day holocaust, look at what is happening in Darfur, Africa. People are being starved to death, etc.
.

2007-01-30 03:25:26 · answer #4 · answered by SAK 6 · 1 0

Genocide is wrong no matter who commits it and on whom. Maybe you should do more readings on the millions of Jews who were tortured, gased, robbed of all things, and left to wither away. Watch a few movies on the subject, Shindler's List, The Piano, Band of Brothers, etc. Do your homework before you ask a stupid question. And believe me, there is such a thing as a "stupid question".
Review your history books, take a few history courses in school, go to the Holocaust Museum, talk with people who have lost family members, research this stuff on the internet... Be resourceful, don't be ignorant.
Become a better human-being, READ.

2007-01-30 03:19:54 · answer #5 · answered by Sarah H 2 · 3 0

wow! thats spoken like a real racist! Good job! Way to go! I think you have a good career with the Aryan Nation.. But to answer your question, because they were singled out merely for their race. Yes many die in wars every day. Most are killed because of their nationality, i.e. belonging to the country fighting. However, the numbers killed during the Holocaust were phenomenal due to the fact they were singled out for being jews. If we went into a nation and killed hundreds of thousands of people in that nation for merely being catholic and over looked the protestants, baptists, islamics etc.. it too would be a holocaust. making it a myth isn't possible because it did happen. They did die. Because they were jews.

2007-01-30 03:18:13 · answer #6 · answered by nickbarrack 1 · 3 1

Read a book about this and then tell me that this is an ordinary way to go about killing other human beings. It is not the only one taken into account. It horrifies not because of its monstrous evil, but because of it focused,monomaniacal industrial banality. I am likely in your lights, and in the estimation of who ever is telling you this soul killing crap, wholly and completely evil and worthy of the most unpleasant death you can think of. I'm so evil I have 999 branded on my forehead; marked up from 666. I. while Irish, have, like the Jews, horns and a tail. I occasionally sacrifice christian babies(Baptist, good fat to to lean) eat them and make flying ointment with the fat. I suffer a witch to live. I draw pictures of God. I pray infrequently.

I fail to understand why I am responsible for describing the factually proven destruction of 6mil. humans wholly on the account of their "race". a Myth. The #1 myth of human kind isit works to slaughter the "other" when things are going badly. Their God is false anyway, their not really people. Our God is on the side of His people.

2007-01-30 03:31:29 · answer #7 · answered by colinchief 3 · 0 0

Denying the Holocaust does nothing to shed light on other genocidal atrocities. Denying the Holocaust would only give more ammunition to criminals who try to wipe out entire races like the Kurds, Armenians, Bosnians, Rwandans, Sudanese, Cambodians, and not to mention the current Darfur conflict.

2007-01-30 03:20:17 · answer #8 · answered by artemisaodc1 4 · 2 0

Give me a better example of genocide.

2007-01-30 03:12:16 · answer #9 · answered by thebobcatreturns 3 · 0 2

people who created this big fraud , published it every where are the people who have in their hands the horns of the world media , they could decide what people have to hear , see and believe

2007-01-30 03:16:07 · answer #10 · answered by mali 6 · 1 4

fedest.com, questions and answers