robbie v take that?

Question

have Take That become equal , to robbie now , should they all shake hands for musics sake ??????///

Answer 1

Take That and Robbie met up with each other during the tour last year. They spent an evening together and it seems they all got on pretty well. TT have always said the door is open for him to join them one time but if Robbie doesnt want to that is his choice. TT are now a 4 peice anyway and really dont need him. It is obvious that TT are doing well on their own, but the press and media just cant seem to let the whole Robbie/Gary thing go. They have met up, made up and moved on, so its about time everybody else did too.

Answer 2

Take That have almost overtaken Robbie now. Robbie has been having a hard time - he didn't manage to break America, he fell out with his songwriting partner that wrote all the good songs, and the label he is on, EMI, expected far too much from him that he hasn't been able to deliver. He is also a messed up paranoid, neurotic guy, so put all that together and he isn't in the best shape. While Take That have just come back and picked up all their old fans through nostalgia. The market that they appeal to is one of the strongest markets to target so they are in a strong position which was proved by the fact that they were the second biggest selling band in 2006 - Snow Patrol beat them. I don't think I would like to see them back with Robbie though - they don't need him so I think they just get on with what they are doing and not get brought down by some of the bad press he has got himself into.

Answer 3

I think that robbie and take that have already met up and made up!

I don't think that take that have become equals yet, they need to have a couple more top selling albums and from what i here from the new album, i think they will eventually bevcome equal if not better than robbie williams

I was a huge take that fan in the 90's and still remain so to this day!

Answer 4

Take That are better than Robbie Williams. Take That have tried to have a reunion with Robbie, but he does not want to know. They don't need him in their group they are doing good as they are.

Think Robbie's latest music is rubbish. He tries to put out too many albums instead of taking time to make them decent.

:-))

Answer 5

I believe Robbie has got a bit too big for his boots lately. Take That are doing very well in their own right. I also believe that it was Robbie who refused a one time reunion. Robbie is good, but not that good.

Answer 6

take that are equal to and possibly better than Robbie they release a new single after ten years and go straight to no 1 where as Robbie is looking for new fans (as the majority of fans he had are or where take that fans) by releasing music which is total and utter s***e compared to what he originally released after leaving take that!!

Answer 7

In my humble opinion I think Take That are just cashing in on nostalgia. maybe they have ran out of money!

I liked take that as a teenybopper in the early 1990's but looking back i think their songs are not that great. I don't like their new songs either.

Robbie is where he is today from all his good songs (and i'm not particularly a robbie fan)

If he was to stop releasing songs for 10 years and then start again I think he would be cashing in on peoples memories too.

So to me anyway, Robbie wins

Answer 8

Robbie Williams should fade into obscurity for musics sake. Luckily that seems to be happening now..

Answer 9

Yeah they should. But as much as I enjoy Robbie's music he is a **** and he will not lower his "standards" to accept that "Take That" could possibly be more talented then him.

Answer 10

I think Robbie has had his day - Take That had a good comeback but I don't think they will last too long