can any one tell me why in India alone these communal reservations are made for the minorities?

Question

other countries in the world hadn't such depolrable rules,the political and enthenic unrest in india is due to this i think,many talented and educated people are loosing their good chances due to this minority system,i want your opinions and suggesstion on this matter,this a very serious matter.

Answer 1

as long as these bring in Votes for the politicians, these reservations will remain. However, things will be different if you ask them to embrace people from the lower caste or if their sons/daughters wish to marry someone from them.

Answer 2

UNLIKE IN OTHER ORGANIZED RELIGIONS, HINDUISM DOES NOT SAY THAT BY WORSHIPING A PARTICULAR GOD OR A BOOK ONLY, A PERSON GETS SALVATION. IT PREACHES THERE ARE SEVERAL WAYS TO REACH GOD. THEY ARE GNANA{KNOWLEDGE}, BHAKTI{DEVOTION},KARMA{DEEDS} YOGA.IN THAT WAY IT GAVE FREEDOM TO ITS SUBJECTS. IN HINDUSIM, EVERY CASTE IS A RELIGION. THE problem with Hindus is they are most tolerant towards other religions. but at the same time, THEY ARE MOST INTOLERANT TO WARDS, DALITHS,WHO ARE STILL REGARDED AS UNTOUCHABLES. STILL IN RURAL AREAS, 2 GLASSES SYSTEM IS FOLLOWED. THAT MEANS IN HOTELS, THE OWNERS MAINTAIN 2 TYPES OF GLASSES 1 FOR UPPER CASTE HINDUS AND ANOTHER FOR DALITHS.UPPER CASTE HINDUS DO NOT ALLOW DALITH HINDUS TO ENTER THE HINDU TEMPLES.FOR EXAMPLE, IN ORISSA, RECENTLY , THE DALITHS WERE DENIED ENTRY INTO A HINDU TEMPLE,CALLED JAGANNADHA SWAMY TEMPLE.HINDUS DON'T BOTHER EVEN IF THE BORDERS OF INDIA ARE INVADED BY FOREIGN FORCES. BUT THEY DO NOT HESITATE EVEN FOR A MOMENT, IF AN UNTOUCHABLE DRINKS WATER FROM COMMON WELL.HINDUS KEEP QUIET EVEN IF THEIR GODS ARE INSULTED BY OTHER RELIGIONS BUT THERE WOULD BE A BLOOD BATH BETWEEN UPPER CASTE HINDUS AND DALITHS AND BETWEEN BACK WARD CASTES AND UPPER CASTE HINDUS. RECENTLY IN MAHARASHTRA, A STATE IN INDIA, ENTIRE FAMILY OF DALITHS WERE TORCHED TO DEATH BY BACK WARD CASTE HINDUS.TILL DATE NO CULPRIT WAS ARRESTED. BUT EVEN AFTER 60 YEARS OF RESERVATION POLICY IMPLEMENTED, A SON OF A COBBLER REMAINS AS A COBBLER AND THE SON OF A TAILOR REMAINS AS A TAILOR. AND THE SON OF A BARBER IS STILL A BARBER. ONLY UPPER STRATA OF DALITHS ARE ENJOYING THE FRUITS OF RESERVATION THUS THEY BECAME CREAMY LAYER AND DEPRIVING OTHERS OF THE FRUITS OF RESERVATION POLICY.for the information of bangaru and others, i bring to their notice that the puranas and vedaas were not written by BRAHMINS. THEY WERE WRITTEN BY THE PEOPLE WHO ARE NOW CALLED DALITHS AND OTHER BACK WARD CASTE PEOPLE. I REQUEST BANGARU TO READ ONCE AGAIN HINDU PURANAS AND VEDAS . VALMIKI, WHO WROTE THE RAMAYANA WAS A BOYA.{SCHEDULED TRIBE} VYASA WHO WROTE THE MAHABHARATA WAS THE SON OF A WOMAN BELONGED TO FISHERMEN COMMUNITY. VASISHTA MARRIED ARUNDHATHI , BELONGING TO THE DALITHS.MOST OF THE HYMNS WRITTEN IN VEDAS WERE NOT WRITTEN BY BRAHMINS.IN THOSE DAYS,THERE WERE NO CASTES. THE FOREIGN RULERS DIVIDED THE PEOPLE ON CASTE BASIS AND RULED THIS COUNTRY FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS.MY OPINION IS THERE IS OF NO USE IN GIVING RESERVATIONS AS THEY DO NOT REACH THE NEEDY PEOPLE. ALL THE DALITHS, ECONOMICALLY BACK WARD PEOPLE SHOULD STRIVE FOR A CLASS LESS SOCIETY.THEN ONLY THEIR PROBLEMS WILL BE SOLVED.

Answer 3

Centuries of racism has caused this. It isn't a problem unique to India either, as the U.S. sturggles with affirmative action and quotas.