"Before They Were Stars" American Idol?

Question

Imagine an American with the following twelve performers before they were stars. Which four are the first ones voted out? Who are the four finalists? Who wins and why?

Britney Spears
Christina Aguilera
Beyonce
Pink
Faith Hill
Aretha Franklin
Justin Timberlake
Michael Jackson
Rob Thomas
Steven Tyler
Ludacris
Harry Connick Jr.

Answer 1

First 4 out:

Rob Thomas - He's not the best-looking or most talented, putting him somewhere in the middle. That's the worst place to be for the early rounds. Quick exit for Rob.

Ludicris - Most of America would find him too edgy to vote for. Even Randy would be telling him to tone it down.

Britney Spears - Simon would say, "Your singing isn't good enough! This isn't a DANCE competition!" and that would be the end of Britney.

Michael Jackson - Skinny Black kids are always early round fodder. The crowd will gasp when the vote is announced, and Ryan Seacrest will say, "You see, America! This is why you have to vote every week!"


Next 4 out:

Beyonce - She'd do fine in the first few rounds. Then there would be theme nights like country music and big band, styles she is not suited for, and she'd get voted out for lack of versatility.

Justin Timerlake - He'd pull the heart-throb vote in the early rounds. In the middle rounds, there is the inevitable backlash against the pretty boys who don't have great voices.

Aretha Franklin - This is usually the time in the competition when the large Black women with powerhouse voices make their exit. By this time, Simon will have suggested two or three times that she lose some weight.

Harry Connick Jr - He'd be pulling in the old lady vote. However, when the number of finalists is down to 5 or 6, this demographic won't be enough to keep him going.


Finalists:

Steven Tyler - The judges would be trashing every one of his performances, telling him to "stop shouting". Despite that, he'd be pulled the rock vote in big numbers and make it to the final 4.

Pink - Punk chicks with weird hair tend to do better than expected, even if they aren't that talented (which is not true for Pink). She makes it to the Final 4.

Faith Hill - She'd have the Country vote locked up. That would carry her to the Final 4, with a shot to win it all.


And the winner...

Christina Aguilera - She'd be on good behavior for this competition, knowing that it's too early in her career to get controversial. Also, she has the "Idol look" (Simon loves blondes) and she has a good voice for this competition.

Answer 2

First 4 out would be Harry Connick Jr., Ludacris, Christina Gaguilera and Steven Tyler!
The 4 finalists would be Michael Jackson, Britney Spears, Faith Hill and Beyonce!
And the winner is......MICHAEL JACKSON because he is the best!!!!!


♥♥We Love You Michael!!!!♥♥

Answer 3

The first four voted out would be Ludacris, Justin Timberlake, Steven Tyler and Michael Jackson
I don't think any of these singers are reallyt hat talented (although some people may disagree with me about Steven tyler lol)

The four finalists:
Beyonce, Pink, Aretha Franklin and Christina Aguilera

I think the winner would be probably Christina Aguilera
Her voice is amazing.. that is all I can say lol :)

Answer 4

the first 4 to be voted out: Britney Spears, Justin Timberlake, Harry Connick Jr and Rob Thomas. The 4 finalists would be: Christina Aguilera, Beyonce, Pink, and Aretha Franklin. The winner would be Beyonce: because she is very talented. she can sing, dance, act and on top of all of that she is gorgeous! She is very down to earth and centered. She does not act like she thinks she is better than anyone else and seems grateful for her success - she is always thanking her family and God! She is very grateful and deserving

Answer 5

The first 4 I would vote out would be Brittney Spears, Christina Aguilera, Micheal Jackson and Ludacris. For those voted off, don't particularly like to see what Brittney or Christina wears or not wears under those tight, little skirts, not to mention I don't think they are good role models for young girls at all, they are skanky in my opinion. 4 Finalists would be Pink , cause I love her attitude and spunk, Aretha Franlklin cause she will always be the Queen of Soul, Faith Hill, as I enjoy her music and voice and last it will be Steven Tyler. But for the first place winner I would choose Steven Tyler. He's been around for a long time and all that time he has done a great job of entertaining fans. I love the music and the lyrics to the songs.

Answer 6

The 1st voted off would be Beyonce & Britney Spears cause shaking your as$ just aint cute when you're a pre-teen.

4 Finalist Are:

Michael Jackson
Aretha Franklin
Faith Hill
Ludracris

Answer 7

well i think the first 4 voted out would be the ones who can sing but not great and just put on a show:

Pink, Britney, Rob Thomas, and Justin

4 finalists: Christina, Beyonce, Aretha and Faith

Winner: Christina - she has great range, and can sing and put on a good act.

Answer 8

first 4 voted out: Britney Spears, Michael Jackson, Ludacris, and Justin Timberlake

4 finalists: Faith Hill, Beyonce, Steven Tyler, and Christina Aguilera

winner - Faith Hill because she's an amazing singer :)

Answer 9

Eddie, i'd say or imagine the note "pitchy" appears like something someone British would say. I for sure will be incorrect, yet I under no circumstances heard that note. I were round music all my existence in a unmarried way or yet another, heard "off pitch" our "out of music" or "flat" or "sharp", yet under no circumstances the note "pitchy". So it purely would have change into popular from American Idol. I did although word that "spell examine" does no longer "comprehend" the note "pitchy" if meaning something or no longer. would that make one imagine there is not any such note in step with se?!..:)

Answer 10

They all suck long live Elliot