How come a Parlimentary system of government can never be a true Democracy?

Question

Best answer wins.

Answer 1

A democracy directly elects their leader. In a parliament, only elected representatives choose a leader.

So in one country with a democracy, all the votes are tallied, and the winner gets to be the leader of the country.

In a country with a parliament, everyone elects thier representative(s). Once they are in place, all of the representatives from around the country elect a leader.

Answer 2

Because instead of working together to solve problems the opposition parties just try to inhibit the passing of bills into law instead of assisting to make them better. Parties push for their agendas instead of the what the majority of the people want. Parties elected into office do not really have 50% of the peoples support as elections usually are only supported by about 50 % of the people. That means that 1/2 of us do not vote. Then the 50% that do vote only support the winning party by about 55% of all the votes cast. So in a way you have a government elected into govern by only about 30% of the people available to vote. Not true democracy because voting could be made simpler but parties in power rarely change it as it seems to serve their purpose.

Answer 3

Democracy is the rule of people. It has many shortcoming but is still best way to govern a country. However, there are established principles. Experience shows that it brings stability to the country provided we learn to respect the opinion of others and give a chance to function it. In a society people are more important. There should not be exploitation of people in the name of democracy.

Answer 4

do not ignore that at that aspect in time, democracy meant direct democracy, which become on the time in many cases noted as mobocracy, astounding or incorrect as which will be, and that republic become yet another type of authorities (type of administration) fullyyt. right here, he ability direct democracy, with the human beings being assembled to vote on public affairs, and is probable especially referencing Athenian "democracy" (the previous party of democracy and the only maximum referenced contained in the Enlightenment at the same time as Rousseau become writing) and bringing up the very authentic critique that it become only a democracy in the event you might want to have the funds for the free time to participate in public affairs; while if it honestly in touch everybody being assembled in any respect cases to vote on each and every count number of public affairs, it would want to be unwieldy and not in any respect some thing except politics, like the turning out to be, making, and transporting of food, outfits, furniture, and so on. If a fee become formed to cope with a count number, it does no longer be the assembled human beings vote casting on each and every thing - a correct away democracy - yet instead some thing else: contained when it comes to what Rousseau is arguing for a republic or what in present day parlance is termed oblique democracy, yet another type of administration.

Answer 5

Because it's not called a democracy it's called a parliment. Just like the constitution in the U.S. , say america shall be a Republic , which I might add also isn't called a Democracy.

Answer 6

Because a true democracy gives each citizen equal power. A parliamentary system elects representatives. So every citizen is not going to find a perfect representative, and even if they find one they like there's no guarantee that their vote will put that person in office to represent them. So, worst case scenario someone whom you don't share views with will end up representing you and acting on your behalf, which is not democracy.

Answer 7

Because a true democracy is a system where each issue is decided by each voter casting a ballot.

In a Parlimentary system, your elected representative casts a ballot for you, whether you agree with him or not.

These two systems differ at their very definition. That's why.

Answer 8

You're voting for a MP instead of voting directly on issues.

Answer 9

Unequal power.