Who else thinks Tom Brady is still better than Peyton Manning?

Question

I'd like to see who agrees and why...thanks!

Answer 1

Hey! Powerlift! Remind me again how many Super Bowls Peyton Manning has won? How many Super Bowl MVP's he's won? What's his career record against Brady? Does Brady get to throw to Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne? YOUR AN EFFIN PANZIE!!!!! BRADY RULES!!!! Oh, and one last question. This one is for the LADIES who choose Manning over Brady (like Wendy): who's HOTTER, Brady or Manning?

Answer 2

While i think brady is better i could also argue that manning is better because of all the great regular season accomplishments he has garnered throughout his carrer. However you have to realize that the entire reason for playing football is to WIN SUPERBOWLS-something Brady has done 3 times in his career- and he's only 29. The reason why Brady is a better quarterback than Manning is not because he puts up bigger numbers- because he doesnt. Its because he wins more with so much less talent around him than manning has had in his carreer. If you look at the talent that this years patriots team had then you would realize how incredible it was that they even reached the AFC championship- never mind coming within 60 seconds of winning it. Regardless of whether or not Manning wins the super bowl this year, Brady is still better because he wins with less and has won 3 as opposed to none or possibly 1. And you must be nuts if you think Brady is done. He'll be only 30 years old next year, not to mention how much more talented his team will be with 30 million in cap space and two first round picks. Let's wait until their careers are over to see who is better. It should be a fun ride.

Answer 3

I do like the fact that Brady can win with just about anything.
The Patriots did not have a 1,000 yard rusher nor 1,000 yard receiver this year and they still came one game away from going to the Super Bowl.

The Colts had (2) 1,000+ yards receivers and (1) 1,000 yard rusher.

If Tom Brady was to ever get a killer Wr or RB or both, the league would be in a lot of trouble. The Pats would run the table for quite a while.

As smart and as good as Peyton is you can't over look Brady's will and drive to get it done.

Answer 4

PEYTON MANNING!!!!!

Tom brady is the second most overrated QB in the NFL (behing Mike Vick). Brady is only good on routes that are run 15 yards and under, all his yards come from swing passes to running backs, thats why there is no 1,000 yard rec. on the Pats, brady does have three rings but super bowls are team accomplishments and not an individual one, Peyton has 2 LEAGUE MVP's yeah thats league wide for the whole season not one game in the playoffs, brady has a far better defense and how many superbowls were won by the legs of ADAM V. brady is a only good on short yardage passes and is very inaccurate after that, how many balls are over thrown by him and how many are under thrown, brady is calm in the pocket but so is manning, Manning is a smarter QB he is the only QB that has the trust of his coach to aud. at the line and change plays on the fly. Manning can throw the deep ball can throw short, he is smarter, has more individual accomplishments and is just better then Tom Brady, Lets see brady go to another team and do what he does in NE, it wont happen, he is a product of his system and thrives on short dink passes that get yards after the catch, thats why they have no deep threat cuz brady cant throw it that far or accurate. Y does Brady get all the glory when they win and recieve no blame when he losses. Everyone needs to get of Tom Brady's Jock and realize that he is not even a great QB. Rings dont matter when your talking about a better QB, SUPER BOWLS ARE TEAM ACCOMPLISHMENTS NOT INDIVIDUAL. so get of Brady's Jock. TOM BRADY = OVERRATED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 5

Probably in past games-but not when it counted.-Peyton Manning is one of a few much heralded Quarterbacks to emerge to prominence in the NFL in a relatively short time span. He played his best game Sunday-with the aid of a motivated and superior team. By comparison- Tom Brady was unheralded in the beginning and emerged to stardom behind solid teams with nearly infallible strategy. The Patriots have run their string.Tom Brady's star is now setting. He will take his place behind even better QB's from the past. Barring injuries he may remain in the NFL-but I believe he should retire while he is still in good physical health. To last even five years in that violent physical environment is unusual. He needs to recognize his good fortune and bow to father time. No one stays on top for long . Furthermore-he has no more to prove.

Answer 6

Not me. Lets look at records. Does Tom Brady have a one yet? I dont think so. He has Super Bowl rings wow that doesnt say a whole lot. So hes been surrounded by a great team. Sorry Peyton still has more 4th quarter comebacks than Brady and last night made it 7 more than Brady. Peyton and Brady still have many years left to play. Stats and records dont lie. And you know I dont need to tell you who has more. So go and cry like Brady and Belichick did last night. Both of them were poor sports after their loss. I lost all respect for both of them last night. Peace out................

Answer 7

I must admit Brady is better than Manning but Manning had the team this year and defense steped up so Colts congrads

Brady is a better quarterback b/c he was there in the spotlight the Super Bowl and he's just on the spot with 4th quarter drives Quarterbacks need an all around season Brady is like that

Answer 8

I have to give credit where credit is due. Tom Brady has won 3 Super Bowls with slightly above mediocre, and at times mediocre offensive talent around him.

Manning was not efficient until he got Edge and Harrison. Now his team is loaded with two good wr's, a solid te, and a good young future back.

Brady has not had a top 10 premier rb or wr with him during his tenure with the Patriots. ( Yes, I know Dillion is there, but his best years are far behind him.)

He has been very fortunate to have a brilliant coach in Bill Belichick guiding him through his success.

Without Belichick's guidance Brady would not have 3 rings.

Answer 9

No one is even taking into consideration all the talent surrounding Manning. If Brady had a Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne (both 1st round picks) to throw too I think he would have Manning's statistic if not more. Brady makes everybody around him look good, even if they suck. Reche Caldwell, where was he all his career before coming to NE? David Patten, David Givens all disappeared after leaving NE. Deion Brach had a dismal year too, his best games are behind him as well. When he won his first super bowl he didn't even have a good running back either. I am not even going to start on his poise...

Answer 10

Manning is alot better passing QB then Brady but Brady does have the 3 rings.