Do you find this to be wrong?

Question

That native americans, especially ones from wealthy tribes, pay absolutely no income taxes, if they have anything delivered to them on native land, say a car, they pay no sales taxes. Yet the state will use our tax money to pay for a new road to go to their casino! I know a couple of natives personally that get $17,000 a MONTH no exaggeration at all seriously $17,000 a month! Just for being native! There are 16 and 17 yr olds driving around in $70,000 vehicles! Then they whine how they are treated unfairly! What?!!! Unfair! A native's girlfriend I work with just turned 18 and bought a $375,000 house, $34,000 worth of furniture, his girlfriend a $60,000 car and also has a hummer valued around $75,000. What is wrong with this country to just let a certain ethnic people live here extremely wealthy and for free! Their only arguement is that we "Stole there land from them." News flash thousands of countries throughout time were founded by conquest not just the US.

I think the billions of dollars they've made since we gave them their sovereign land and casinos has more than paid for what happened to them! I have more respect for Paris Hilton then I do for any spoiled native!

So, for any injustice that happened long before any of our time should be paid for with reparations? If that;s the case just about every race, religion, creed, culture or nationality should be titled to some kind of reparation. Everyone acts like this is the only case of injustice to ever happen throughout time!

Answer 1

What I can't understand is whatever happened to free enterprise in this so-called Capitalistic Government? If Casinos are allowed, why are they only allowed for the Indians?

Bad Rat!!!! I just pulled the Rug out from all those nice Indians we once had to fight! Bad Bad Rat!!!

Answer 2

Actually, it's a bit more complicated than 'we stole their land from them.'

To most intents and purposes, the Indian nations that exist in within the borders of the United States of America are independant nations. Treaties granting tribal sovereignty were struck between the US government and the remaining tribes of Native Americans when they finally gave up their land.

http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/ntreaty/ntreaty.htm

You are incorrect about federal income tax. Here's a link which answers most of your question, including the reason why some American Indians receive payment from the US government.

http://www.narf.org/pubs/misc/faqs.html

To address your concerns over fairness--look at it this way. In return for the benefits Native Americans have now, our ancestors, and ourselves, got a huge country, which has become the greatest and most powerful the world has ever seen. We've gotten the better part of the bargain, don't you think?

Given the number of times the US government broke or ignored the treaties they made with the Indian nations, it's more than appropriate that we honor those agreements. Our history with them is dishonorable enough without compounding it by arbitrarily deciding that we just don't want to any more. America is supposed to stand for freedom, honor, integrity, human rights; we certainly didn't embody those in our dealings with the native peoples of this land. We can't change that history, but we can at least be decent enough not to forget it.

Answer 3

I am not a Native American, but I can tell you that there is a lot more to the story than what you are presenting here.

I would never begrudge a Native American a single penny. They had atrocities done to them that you can't even imagine. They were stolen from not that long ago as well as in the past.

If you want to get upset about something, find out about how much money your state's elected officials in Washington are getting from lobbyist both above and below the table to enact laws or block them that DO NOT benefit you. How about that they get the best medical and dental care money can buy while millions here in the US go without?

Get upset about Native Americans getting reimbursed for what happened to their culture and race? Not me. I applaud them!

Answer 4

an truly ill mama dogs is an quite stressful difficulty. and that i understand your anger at various the solutions that you received. that is widely used that you should want to vent decrease back to those human beings a number of your anger and frustration. So, attempt to proceed to be calm and keep your concentration on your dogs & domestic dogs. do not enable this cloud your authentic purpose - a healthy dogs. And certain, i might want to like to understand this result. Kudos to you on your quick action in being concerned for 7 domestic dogs! it isn't basic! I want that extra human beings might want to comprehend that there are circumstances that stump even the finest of vets. at the same time as the calicum challenge is the most person-friendly with those indicators, it isn't the in user-friendly words reason. And your dedication to this dogs and her domestic dogs is very, very admirable. So, you recognize that you're responding to this disaster contained in the most acceptable way conceivable. you're doing all you would possibly want to do in an quite puzzling difficulty. enable God handle some thing else. Peace

Answer 5

I dont understand this either same with african americans trying to get money from the slave days. Im not a racist but that was a long time ago.

Answer 6

They can also committ crimes (even murder) and then go back onto the reservation and NOT face charges for them. The casino money aside this is comlete BULLS**T!

Answer 7

Hey their making money dont hate! The U.S gov't does this for a reason. Since they refused to pay them reparations they get to make all that money.

Answer 8

But the US were among the few to combine it with genocide.
Stop moaning and begrudging.
Find solace in the thought that you did not leave too many.

Answer 9

It is ongoing reparations for stealing their land, slaughtering most of the and trying to assimilate the few that managed to survive.

Answer 10

not to mention, WE didn't steal THEIR land, because WE and THEY weren't alive when it happened.

i have no doubt you'll be flamed for asking this.