Does anyone agree with that article that said that Carlos Zambrano is the most underrated pitcher?

Question

I heavily DISAGREE cause Carlos Zambrano isnt that good infact he has awful control, no dominant pitcher, he walks like 20 batters per game, he doesnt strike out that many hitters, he one time lost a game to the Pittsburgh Pirates.
The most underrated pitcher is Josh Beckett and Curt Schilling and Im a Yankees fan.

Answer 1

Most underrated? Tell that to my fantasy roster. I have had him off and on the past 3 years. Does he have good stuff? Yes, he absolutely does. But, he is so inconsistent, that for every 1 Ace, say a game where he does pitch more than 5 innings, he has at LEAST 3 where his era is like 21.00 for the game.
You are right, low ks, high bbbs, and not consistently dominant.

Answer 2

Carlos Zambrano is indeed underrated.

Most people think thats it's all about the strike outs and balls. In reality it is hoe many pitches it takes to get an out for a pitcher. Carlos Zambrano is on the top of the list. I would find more amazing to see a pitcher have a 48 pitch game with no strikeouts then a pitcher have a 138 pitch game with 17 strikeouts.

I think that Dice-K is more underrated. In the WBC he dominated any batter he faced from the mlb. There is a reason Japan won. I am always surprised to here that people think he will get lower then 15 wins. In my mind he will get 18-20 wins. The Red Sox do their research on a pitcher before using their money. They would not waste that much money on a player. The Red Sox also said that Dice- K was worth 100m+, but since they had to pay the seibu lions they didn't give 100m+ to Dice-K contract. In coming years he might have a 100m+ contract.

Another underrated pitcher is Curt Schilling. All i here about is always Johan Santana or some of those other elite guys. But Curt Schilling is amazing and he always does what he needs to do. He never goes down without a fight.

I actually think that Josh Beckett is overrated. This might of been because of an off year, but he was still overrated in my book. If you watch all the games he has pitched he has given up almost all the runs in the first inning. His ERA is horrible. I am hopping he will bounce back this year, but this was an overrated year for him.

This is coming from a Red Sox fan so those are the only pitchers I will talk about, although almost every pitcher is underrated or overrated.

Answer 3

Carlos Zambrano is in no way overrated, he is completely underrated. I agree that you might be thinking of Victor Zambrano, because Carlos is a great pitcher.

And no, I'm not a Cubs fan, I'm a Sox fan, and I disagree that Josh Beckett is underrated. he had double-digit losses last year, a few more than Curt Schilling, and he's paid $10 Million a year. Curt Schilling was better than he was last year and he was 39/40, where Beckett is still in his mid 20's.

Answer 4

Ok Beckett and Schilling are underrated? You have got to be kidding me. Beckett gave up 36 home runs and his era was over 5. I don't believe you are supposed to give a pitcher any credit for that. You are a yankees fan so you should remember he walked 9 batters in one game. Schilling is starting his decline now too, his time is up. Zambrano is underrated. Just cause he lost a game to the Pirates doesnt mean he's a bad pitcher. Pedro Martinez once lost to the Pirates does that make him overrated?
When it comes down to pitching it is keepin your team in striking distance to give them a chance to win and that is what Zambrano did last year. His team didn't have that much offensive pop yet he went out and pitched his *** off and he was 16-7 on a team under 500. He does have a high walk count but he does have over 200 k and last time i checked that is striking out many hitters. He was ranked 4th in the nl in strike outs and 5th in the MLB.
I'm sorry to tell you but you really got your facts mixed up on this one.
And Popular you say Dice-K dominated any major league hitter he faced in the WBC, the best MLB hitter he faced was Jorge Cantu, so how can you get an accurate estimation of how good this guy is going to be. He never even won 20 games in Japan and the way he is hyped it sounds like hes going to win 30 here.

Answer 5

Carlos Zambrano is underrated. His walks about an average amount of batters considering his innings pitched and his strikeout totals are right where they should be. "he one time lost a game to the Pittsburgh Pirates"? Pittsburgh had 67 wins last season. I bet Zambrano isn't the only great pitcher to lose one. Thats pretty much the dumbest statement I've heard today.

I don't think anyone thinks Josh Beckett and Curt Schilling are anything but great, so I don't think they're underrated.

Answer 6

Zambrano gets a good amount of press and he is not underrated. He is the best pitcher the Cubs have and I don't think hooked up right in the head. An underrated pitcher is a good pitcher who doesn't get enough credit. Beckett was not very good last year and Schilling when he wasn't hurt was average at best. Plus when you have pitched as long as Curt has he really can't be underrated. Papelbon was underrated. He was fantastic but really didn't get the props.

Answer 7

Schilling underrated?You gotta be kidding!!He gets plenty of hype and a few years ago was the Red Sox number 1.But he is near the end and can't be thought of the same,but underrated?No Way And Beckett should have stayed with the Marlins.He hasn't been worth his money.
Now for Zambrano.He is too emotional and lets it get the best of him more than he should.He walks too many hitters and puts himself in bad situations that he shouldn't be in.He should be able to win if he is getting run support of 4 runs a game.But he lets the bad inning or bad call get the better of him.If he controlled his emotions better and had a pitching coach who could teach him control and how to pitch instead of throwing,he'd be a lot better.He is no way the most underrated,in fact he might be the most overrated.

Answer 8

Zambrano was on the worst team in baseball last season, and he still had a winning record. The man can pitch. I'm not sure if he's underrated. Most baseball people believe he has been the ace of the Cubs for quite awhile.

The pathetic sheep who root for the Cubs think Wood and Prior are great pitchers. They are not. Zambrano is the only pitcher that sad-sack organization has.

Answer 9

properly in the adventure that your crew is play like crap, then he does have a correct to say some thing. he's likewise pointing out the glaring. The numbers coach this. And in some unspecified time sooner or later, the crew and the administration needs to comprehend that this isn't a curse, they merely have a crew, for some reason can no longer preform as a crew.i do not imagine there is a few thing which will be executed, a minimum of no longer some thing short of doing away with everybody, trading for brand spanking new gamers and both getting a clean stadium or transferring to get a clean start up. as far as calling them a AAA crew, it would want to be unfair on the grounds that maximum different AAA communities might want to probable play extra effective in the adventure that they ought to play on the MLB aspect. BQ:i'm hoping he demands to be traded. you should experience undesirable for a guy who's one among the most acceptable pitcher, and probable the most acceptable participant on the crew commonly. He should be on a crew that wins.

Answer 10

"Awful control, too many walks, not enough strike outs" - you must be talking about VICTOR Zambrano and not Carlos.

It happens that, starting after the All Star Game, I keep track of every starting pitcher whom I believe has a chance at winning that year's Cy Young award in each league. I go back to the start of the season to pick up their stats, and I do splits that you don't normally see done, and I see a lot of surprising and not so surprising results.

Yes, this past season, Carlos Zambrano lost to the Pirates, not once but twice, but he got a total of 4 runs in support in those two games. That saw slightly less than his season average of run support in games that he lost, which was 2.14

In the meantime, Curt Schilling was getting an average of 3.29 runs support in his losses. And as for Josh Beckett, the farther into the season he went, the more his stats deteriorated. By the end of August, I had taken him off my list, and with good reason.

Pitching is not about blowing away batters. Pitching is about disrupting the timing of batters, about fooling batters into getting themselves out. And if you can get a batter to bounce into a 6-4-3 DP in 2 pitches instead of striking him out in three or five or ten or more, you're more than doing your job.

Pitching, really pitching, is about guts and guile as much as it is about fastballs and sliders. It's about getting batters out as quickly and efficiently as is possible. Did you know, for example, that just to prove a point, Jim Palmer once threw a SHO in which he threw nothing but fastballs, didn't walk a batter and didn't strike one out, either. (Yes, he was yet again trying to prove a point to Earl Weaver, and I'd say he did just that.)

Carlos Zambrano UNDERRATED!!!!!!! Heck, he was my choice for NL CY.