In your opinion, who is the NFL's best QB and why?

Answer 1

I have to agree with what seems to be the consensus here. Tom Brady is the best QB of our generation hands down. His accomplishments so far: Best overall playoff record all time, three rings in five seasons (possibly going on 4 in 6) and he beats the highly overrated Peyton Manning almost all the time. Which he will again on Sunday by the way. But the way I really come to this conclusion is by asking myself one simple question: It's fourth down and seven, playoff time, you need a first down or your season is over, you can have any current QB you want for that one play; who do you want? It's Brady all the way baby! He's Mr. Clutch. That's why Brady is the best.

Answer 2

Any QB that can win another super bowl for the rams.

Realistically, Probably have to go with Tom Brady. He may not always look great during the regular season but when the playoffs come around he just can't be beet. That is where it matters the most. Sorry Patton Manning, you always look good in the regular season but you choke on a big one when you meat Brady in the post season. My prediction for the weekend...NE 35 Indy 24. Pats win another Ring.

Answer 3

Tom Brady. He doesn't have the greatest QB rating, but is currently the best big game quarterback. 12-1 in the playoffs, 3 Superbowls, 2 MVPs for those Superbowl games.

I think the Chargers game was a perfect example of what makes him great. He didn't have a great game, but he didn't panic and managed some great drives when it was needed.

You can argue about who might be a better passer or is more mobile, but with the game on the line and less than 2 minutes to go...none better than Brady.

Answer 4

Tom Brady. Given the fact that he is a 3 time Super Bowl champion and 2 time Super Bowl MVP. Peyton could be the best if he could just get to the Super Bowl and get the MVP.

Answer 5

I would say Manning is the best QB. Brady is great because he has a better collection of talent around him.

If you were going to pick your Fantasy team, you would select Manning over Brady 100% of the time.

Answer 6

Tom Brady

He's got three super bowl rings, and hasn't had much to work with except Deion Branch. Whereas Peyton has Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, and Dallas Clark.

Answer 7

I have to go w/ the rings and Tom Brady has three he almost unstopable in the post season(12-1 lost 2 Denver in divisional round last year). And since we're talking about rings i think ill throw Big BEN in there come on 2 AFC champ games in his 1st two seasons and a ring in the second he great QB who needs to get healthy.
GO STEELERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 8

Trent Green because he's hot!

Just kidding. I do like him, but I'm not going to say that he is the best quarterback in the NFL. Peyton Manning would probably be my number 1, but I also think that the Eagle's McNabb is good, too. However, I will admit I am biased against teams I don't like. ;-)

Answer 9

Right now....?

1) Peyton Manning - cause he's efficient and knows how to lead his team. Good Leader. Good Stats.
2) Brett Farve - Good man. Had been in this sport for so long and is wise. Knows what plays to call
3) Drew Brees - Good calls. Good plays. also knows his guys.
4) Tom Brady - unpredictable. good passes. good player. (not to mention 3 super bowls!) underdog attitude.
5)Tony Romo - stepped up for Bledsoe. Led team to playoff game.
6) Philip Rivers - Good Decisions. Good Running back on his team. Best record in NFL for '06-'07
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
32) Rex Grossman - yeah he's just bad @ everything :)
hahaha

~Go Colts~
~Manning's gonna take all this year~

Answer 10

Tom Brady, three Super Bowl Rings and he's hot on and off the Football Field.