How did Hezbollah defeat Israel and forced the resignation of Ehud Olmert?

Question

forcing sorry

IDF Chief of Staff Lieutenant-General Dan Halutz on Tuesday night announced his resignation as head of the military.

The deputy chief of staff, Moshe Kaplinsky, will act as the interim head of the armed forces.

Senior General Staff officers welcomed Halutz's decision, saying it was
necessary in view of what has come to light regarding the IDF's wartime functioning. "The time has really come," a general who played an active role in the war told Haaretz on Tuesday night.

"[Former GOC Northern Command] Udi Adam indicated the proper moral path with his decision [to resign]. Now Halutz joins him as well - and the inquiries show only the tip of the iceberg regarding Halutz's functioning during the war."

Ehud Olmert's bureau said the prime minister knew ahead of time of Halutz' intention to resign, and had asked him reconsider. Olmert accepted the resignation, however, once he became convinced of Halutz' determination to do so, and expressed deep regret at the decision.

Halutz' decision to step down comes against a backdrop of failures in IDF functioning, his own performance and the performance of the army during the war against Hezbollah in July and August of last year.

Two weeks ago, Halutz said he would resign if the government-appointed Winograd committee of inquiry found him responsible for the mishandling of the war in Lebanon. The Winograd committee is also separately looking into the conduct of Olmert and Defense Minister Amir Peretz.

"If the committee hands down an unambiguous sentence, it would obligate me [to resign]," Halutz had said. The resignation, however, comes before the committee has released its conclusions.

Senior IDF officers testified before the Winograd committee that they considered Halutz responsible for the failures of the war. The officers told the members of the panel that the IDF had made a rushed recommendation to go to war, without preparing the units needed and without devising an exit strategy.

In his letter of resignation to the prime minister and defense minister, Halutz said the responsibility of command led him to the decision that he must remain in the army until internal military investigations had been completed, and the lessons learned from the war incorporated into the IDF's 2007 strategic plan.

Given that this process was completed at the start of January, Halutz asked to resign his post, effective immediately.

In his letter to Olmert, Halutz wrote: "For me, the word responsibility has great meaning. My view of responsibility is what led me to remain in my post until this time and to place this letter on your desk today... Since the echoes of battle ceased, I decided to act responsibly according to the best traditions and values from home and from my service in the IDF."

Halutz said that after the conclusion of the inquiries "I feel proud that I completed what I set out to do. After these thorough processes, I am sure the IDF will be ready to meet the challenges ahead."

Halutz had since the end of the war resisted calls for his resignation, both from the public and within the army.

"I see that there are a number of people who are longing for me to resign. I have no intention of yielding and if you ask me the question again, I will give you the same answer," he told reporters several weeks ago.

"I am not on 'A Star is Born,' and I am not being voted on by SMS. I have not heard those who appointed me call for me to go, when they tell me to do so, then I will respond."

In the near future Peretz will have to present the cabinet with a candidate to be the next chief of staff.

Kaplinsky is an obvious choice for the position, but also mentioned are Ground Forces Commander Benny Gantz, and reserve major-generals Gabi Ashkenazi (who is currently the Defense Ministry director-general), Shlomo Yanai and Ilan Biran.

The July-August assault on Lebanese Hezbollah guerrillas drove them from Israel's northern border but failed to retrieve the two soldiers whose abduction had sparked the conflict, prompting many Israelis to call for a purge of the top brass in hope of restoring Israel's military superiority in the region.

CHEEKY

Retired IDF general Dan Shomron recently submitted the findings of a probe he conducted into the war's execution.

The report, released in part last month, criticised IDF commanders for poor organization during the war, but stopped short of calling for Halutz's resignation.

Halutz, a former Israel Air Force chief, came under criticism for relying heavily on aerial barrages in the first part of the war, which caused extensive damage to Lebanon's infrastructure, while Hezbollah launched around 4,000 rockets into Israel.

Halutz was made chief of staff in June 2005, just before Israel launched its unilateral disengagement from the Gaza Strip.

The appointment raised eyebrows as it meant early retirement for the chief of staff at the time, Lieutenant-General Moshe Ya'alon, who had publicly warned that the Gaza plan would embolden Palestinian militants sworn to Israel's destruction.

Answer 1

They did not defeat Israel. Israel still exists does'nt it? If you read the bible you will know that Israelis are God's chosen people. Israel will go on forever, sorry to rain on your parade. Hezbollah are nothing but cowards. They put civilians in the way of the Israeli bombs, and political correctness saved their sorry asses. I would keep bombing them back to the 1st century.LONG LIVE ISRAEL and the UNITED STATES

Answer 2

lol, Who is going to admit that, no one. Plz dont try with the people here because they are soo much into America and the American Dream, they dont realize that the americans are giving them this dream because to let them not see what is happening outside.

they only listen to what they hear and they dont see because thier media is mistaking them and not letting them know the truth. They only knew that people in israel were dying but didnt know or see how many people in lebanon and mostly KIDS died by the crutial attacks of the non-merciful israel. they say that israel is protected by GOD from the bible, it will be protected if they leave the palestianians alone and the lebanese and mind their own business.

Come on people WAKE UP. you wanna know the truth go to palestine and to lebanon and see and hear the truth.

WAKE UP

Answer 3

Remember that primarily the Israeli armed forces is created in a way to fight traditional battles against the combined armed forces of Egypt, Syria and Jordan.

Hezbollah, however, fights Israel in geurilla-like warfare. In such a war, Israel cannot win, since it is not prepared for such a battle.
However, we can't say that Hezbollah defeated Israel; even if senior officials in the Israeli army resigned due to harsh criticism.

Till now, Israel suffered one only defeat in its entire history; the October War in 1973. Yet this defeat was indecisive; thanks to the American help and interference. After that Israel was greatly secured by the Egyptian flight to the western camp. From now on, Israel will fight the Palestinians and Lebanese only, because Syria and Jordan are much weaker than being able to wage war on the Zionist state.

Now till the emergence of Imam Mahdi, and his control over the then united Islamic world, Israel will exist and prosper. After that, Imam Mahdi will vanquish the Zionists at Armaggedon and destroy Medinat Yisrael forever.

Answer 4

Did I miss the news alert on CNN..."Israel Defeated"? It is still on Google Earth. Oops, looks like you're wrong. Or did you think the resignation of 1 general in Israel or any other country defines defeat? What? He was their only general? I am surprised.

Give me a break.

Answer 5

Hezboolah needs some more victory. I'm sure Israel will be glad to give it to them.

Answer 6

They'd never come close to that on Israel's worst day.

Answer 7

maybe.