Who is better QB vick or mcnabb?

Answer 1

I think Vick is a better running back, but since the question was who is a better QB then it's Mcnabb.

Answer 2

Okay everyone asks this question and the answer is Mcnabb, Vick is a great athlete possibly the best in the NFL, but he has had injury probs just like mcnabb, so thats the same with both. Mcnabb cant throw as far but is a smarter QB so doesn't need to (plus he has Andy reids offense). Running Vick would win he is a better Rb than mcnabb. but what it comes down to is when its 4th quarter and you have a chance to win who do you give the ball to? a experienced, smart, leader who has done it a bunch of times including in the playoffs? or Vick a guy who is gonna Try to do it all on his own by doing what he does best scrambling and running not scoring and winning. The answer is Mcnabb.

Answer 3

McNabb, although Vick's arm has gotten better. McNabb is sitll a bit inconsistent, but I think he ended up with one of the best QB ratings this season.

Anyone who says Vick is a better running back - have you seen McNabb shake off and stiff arm linebackers? Do you remember his 13 second scramble in the backfield against Dallas last seaon, where he broke several tackles and still completed the pass? He's a laid back kind of guy, so I tihnk Garcia brings a necessary spark to the team. Not sure how fired up Vick gets during games.

As someone said, McNabb is very good when forced to scramble, so flushing him out of the pocket doesn't do you any good. He also doesn't get rattled under pressure or after he's been sacked.

Answer 4

Vick is a better athlete, McNabb is a better overall QB.

And we will find out who is better soon, Brady or Manning. I would like to see Peyton make it to the big game. But, I would also like to see Da Bears and New England again as well.

One of the first SuperBowls I remember is the Bears v. Pat's back in the day. I think it would be a better game then their last meeting. At least, I hope so.

Answer 5

If I wanted a running back, I'd give it to Vick.

If I wanted a QB... McNabb all the way. And I mean that in every sense of QB...

If I was told I wanted to pick a scrambling QB, I'd choose McNabb... he is:
Better than most in scrambling...
One of the Smartest QB's...
One of the most accurate QB's...
and as a kicker, probably is the most accurate QB when he is on the move.
Plus he's a great teammmate and person.
He won't "scramble" as effectively as Vick... but he will beable to scramble very well and throw accurately on the move, giving him the advantage of versatility.


Vick... Vick can run better than most RB's, but he is not too smart and not too accurate. He's one of the most dangerous quaterbacks for a team whose defense is not known for their speed. He's also the probably the most dangerous QB to his coaches (carrers) and teammates.

Overall: McNabb is better QB

Answer 6

McNabb in words of only quarterbacking.Vick is recuperating yet hasn't precisely shown himself as an awesome passer, in the meanwhile McNabb has stats to back it up. Vick can run yet McNabb could also. Vick is a extra useful scrambler, yet McNabb is a extra genuine QB

Answer 7

Mcnabb is a better QB, but it would be really interesting to see what Vick could do coached by someone like Andy Ried. Vick has way more tallent, but Mcnabb has used his tallent better.

Answer 8

better Qb= McNabb
better player= Vick
better athlete= Vick
better teammate= McNabb

Answer 9

McNabb has it all over Vick as a quarterback. He throws with better accuracy, makes better decisions, doesn't panic under pressure and he's not too shabby as a runner either although Vick has him there. He has at least been to the Superbowl.

Answer 10

Mcnabb.