what would you do if someone spanked thier child in public?is spanking okay?

Answer 1

I would be encouraged if i saw someone spanking their child in public, encouraged that american parents hold on their children has not totally gone to crap. It is so discouraging seeing kids running away from parents, or yelling at their parents, or worse cursing at their parents or hitting them. I'd rather see a mom turn around and discipline her child. Not beat their child till they are unconcious or curse at their child or even slap their child acorss the face. Im not talking about that kind of unnecessary punishment. But if parents disciplined their children in the first place this wouldnt have to happen.

Answer 2

When you see a person , let's say a mother chastising her child in public, you're supposed to leave them alone. After all, it's none of your business. However, in my case, I can't tolerate corporal punishment. Especially to innocent children. Their comprehension of discipline is limited. The mother has the obligation to discipline the child . . Although the Bible says, "Spare the rod and spoil the child".

Some children can become so manipulative and act up in public. They know they would get away with their non-acceptable behavior in public. However, discipline should be constant.; aside from being fair. A child should be able to recognize and acknowledge that mom means business.

An effective form of discipline doesn't have to include harsh beating or spanking. Try not to hit the child in anger. There are laws against child abuse. As a professional nurse, I'm required by law to report any suspected child abuse.


I, myself never spanked my own kids. I employed logical reasoning. or stern scolding. I cite and show examples. I employed a lot of compliments and praises for good behavior. I don't yell. I gave a lot of verbal warnings. and time out. I was a widow for 8 years. And I know my techniques worked because my duaghters turned out to be good, kind considerate.

Now, my grandkids are so behaved both in private and in public. I smother them with kindness and love. I sing praises about them to others and within their earshot. No, spanking is not a good idea. It's barbaric. and archaic. It tend to leave a lot of emotional scars on the child. Only an inmature and a mean person would employ this measure of discipline.

Answer 3

In my opinion it is actually wise to spank your child, but it should NEVER be done in anger. When I was younger and misbehaved in public, my mother would take me into a restroom and spank me there. Each time she would spank me she would explain to me what I had done wrong and why it was wrong and then tell me that she was only punishing me because she loved me. I didn't understand back then why she would spank me if she loved me so much, but now I'm very grateful that she did. It has saved me from an immense amount of trouble and heartache.

Thanks mom....

Answer 4

spanking is definately ok. i wasnt alive then but back in the day kids were more disciplined. cause their parents spanked them. now kids dont get spanked and they are little sh*theads. im gonna spank my kids. but only when they most deserve it and i will never beat them. that is wrong. spanking is different from beating. givin them a paddle on the behind is different from beating the crap out of them. now if i saw a parent SPANKING their child in public i would not have a problem with it. but if they beat their child i would go and physically stop them. but thats just me.

Answer 5

We have all kinds of people labelling anything that makes a child uncomfortable "abuse". Spanking is something that should be reserved for situations that have escalated past a certain point and it should be certain to happen once that point is reached. We have parents that are afraid to correct their own kids.

Answer 6

I don't believe in spanking either, however spanking without leaving marks is legal. That appalls me. But the thing to do if you see a parent out of control wih there child is not to chastise them about being abuseive etc. You will only put that child in further danger when they are alone.
You may approach them with words of empathy for how hard it is to be a parent. ie : "It's so frustrating to shop with kids in tow, isn't it" that kind of thing. It helps the parent remember they are in public and reminds them of their inappropriate behavior.

Answer 7

a lot smarter at the moment? i'm not so confident about that. i imagine little ones have continuously been smart and able to reasoning. (a minimum of they have for the in simple terms proper few thousand years.) that is in simple terms that as technologies has made our lives "extra common", adults now have the time to understand what a baby is able to. ... yet that is an entire different situation, isn't it? i imagine that is continuously suitable to commence with different sorts of self-discipline. yet there are situations at the same time as a good spanking is strictly what some childrens want to snap again into good habit. in case you are able to dodge going that far consisting of your man or woman childrens, that is magnificent! yet at times time outs and lectures do not artwork. you in effortless words jogged my memory of one time that i replaced into very tempted to spank my daughter yet opted for a proof truly. lengthy tale short, she and yet another lady ran off interior the park. when I stuck as a lot as her, I defined why what she did replaced into so incorrect. very few steps after telling her there "should be snakes", we said one on the nature path direction they were attempting to take. It made a lengthy-lasting impact. 3 years later she nonetheless sticks close and makes confident i recognize the position she is any time we are taking section in outdoors.

Answer 8

Spanking is most definitely not OK, and if someone was doing it in public I'm sure lots of people would go up to that person and tell them to stop.