why does traditional music from england, scotland and ireland changed much?

Question

I have a lot of music from around the world, and different time periods, which brought me to notice that folk music from the meditteranean, central europe, and eastern europe have changed alot, (most likely evolving during the 1700's) but the british isles folk music still sounds the same as the music from the middle ages that the rest of europe used.

Answer 1

I would say you don't really have good grasp of medieval music is you think British/Scottish/Irish Trad sounds medieval. I sing a lot of Trad from the Isles and I'm also fairly well versed in several medieval styles (Plainsong, Cantigas, and Troubadour music especially) and they are VERY different.

I think if research more true medieval music, you'll start to hear the difference as well.

Answer 2

Yes, if you study the history of Europe then you'll learn that in Renaisance the people of Italy was the most dominant, that's mean evolve more then others. While in Baroque, the German, but Italy are still. In the end of Romantic the France until the modern.


Without lower the England.
If you learn from the past, ussually the open minded Nation/Civilization will develop more, while the closed nation will soon loose.

In Renaisance German was evolving since there was where the Christianity open there mind and welcome the Protestant of Marthin Luther. At that time maybe the England was to proud of themself since they conquer almost the whole island right? they become proud and think that they're the best, that mean stay narow minded. (This is not a political statement)



Hope this Help
Bless You

Answer 3

The reformation, an exceedingly complicated subject rely certainly, become carried with the aid of in eire too, in spite of the shown fact that it tended to difficulty in maximum cases the ruling classes, the so-stated as anglo-irish, who generally accompanied the prevalent Church of eire. This kind of corresponded with the Anglican Church in England. THe greater hardcore varieties of protestantism (anglicanism retained a great form of 'catholic' beneficial aspects like the eucharist, vestments, bishops and so on) alongside with prebyterianism got here somewhat later and, as different solutions have alluded to, pertained in maximum cases to the North (as a great form of the seventeenth century settlers there got here from Scotland the place the prebyterian church become prolific). So all of eire become 'protestant' in a feeling. the conventional human beings in all danger caught to their catholicism initially via fact it become all that they had, yet additionally via fact it must be traced decrease back to the pre-catholic celtic church (eire become christianised plenty until now than England) which had and has an exceedingly substantial place interior the Irish psyche. It become in basic terms later while the clearer conflict lines between protestant and catholic (ie interior the seventeenth century with the boyne and competing claims for the united kingdom throne) emerged, that folk began to work out it alongside those lines. And catholicism did no longer die out in England - northwest England in specific retained a good catholic presence; a great form of basic English human beings thought that protestants have been somewhat loopy. Charles II switched over to Catholicism on his deathbed and his brother James II become a Catholic. They have been quite repressed however. So the question oversimplifies issues, yet substantial writers on the time I examine history (approximately 15 years in the past meaning there must be some greater moderen, greater beneficial stuff) have been JJ Scarisbrick from the Catholic "area', and Christopher Hill from the Protestant area.

Answer 4

This is because their music was one way to fight the British domination. Many of the songs and melodies were and are anti-British propaganda.

Answer 5

um..

Answer 6

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!