Why do Neo-Lib Anti-Theist try to pretend that anti-Zionism isn't antisemitism?

Question

Or alternately that anti-Semitism means anti-“people of the East” instead of anti-Judaism?

I think the subtly of my question was lost on a few people.

Robbie j, I think my question is perfectly clear, a bit over your head perchance?

Benjamin, would I have posed this question had I not known the New Left definition? Do you know the JAZ can count David Duke among their allies?

Ohhbother This is not my attempt to create a ‘buzzword’. I might have ‘coined’ the term in this forum, but neolibralism is a real political belief. All liberals that are capitalists are Neo-Libs.

The answer guy- I understand that, but I believe a vote against Israel is a vote against Jews. Also, why the need to insult me for my belief?

Answer 1

well because they think that if they use tricky little word the fact that they are haters will go away and all teh while they can tell people who dont think how they do that are haters.
its a sign of malignant oblivious ignoramuses who think they are clever.

Benjamin he didnt ask if anti-zionism and anti-sematism were the same thing. He asked about liberal and atheist types and what they suggest it means when you know what they really mean something else.

Answer 2

Because, technically, Palestinians are Semitics too. Do some research.

Also, just because you are against the completely against the creation of Israel (a huge mistake based mostly on emotional reactions to the horrible Holocaust) doesn't mean you're anti-Semitic. However, now that Israel is there, we can't do anything about it, and should support it as a state with a right to exist just like any other country, whether it made sense to create it or not.

Answer 3

they don't look inevitably the same. Antisemitism skill hatred of Jews. Anti-Zionism skill competition the life of Israel. however, maximum human beings of those who oppose Israel benefit this because they hate Jews, or a minimum of regard them as an inferior type of human. in this sense, both are appropriate. obviously there is mostly lack of understand-how in touch. it is been repeated numerous circumstances that Israel stole the land from the Arabs. if fact study that Israel, Jordan, West economic company and Gaza all belonged to the Turks, not Arabs, for most centuries earlier Israel and Jordan were depending. the reason they don't belong to the Turks anymore is that the Ottoman Empire fell aside. yet when human beings do not understand this little bit of historic past, they could believe that Israel's land changed into taken far flung from Arabs.

Answer 4

Anti-semitism and anti-zionism are two completely different things.

Technically, a semite is anyone of middle eastern origin, including Jews. "Anti-semitism" has been coined as "Anti-jewish", which is an inaccurate usage.

A zionist is someone who believes in the jewish state of Israel and its primacy above all other legal, moral, and ethical factors. Not all jews are zionists and not all zionists are jews.

Roll that around in your empty little head for a while, then we can talk.

Answer 5

To call criticism of Zionism Antisemitism, is a club used by the Jewish Lobby groups to justify their own positions. I don't think the two are indistinguishable, nor are they mutually exclusive. I do know, however; that speaking out against state sponsored crimes and the national dis-inheiritance of the Palestinian Nation is no vice. Settlements are built on stolen land, and established by blood and cruelty. In speaking the truth I will take any label you wish to bestow upon me.

Answer 6

Because Atheists have small brains to think that there is no God, they try to cover it up because they HATE religion, and if they bash on Jews they seem antisemetic. ANti-theists dont hate Jews, maybe some, but most dont, they think the religious are foolish for beliveing the way we do. Our best hopes sre just to ignore those fools.And if they try to come back at u with evolution (the answer to how, not why) ponder them "How did those fish or particles or radioactive materials form? Were they just 'there', if so u are going against your reason."

Answer 7

Anti-Zionism isn't anti-Semitism.

Zionism is a political idealogy while Judaism is a religion. That's not the same.

There are even Jews against Zionism, are they being anti-semetic too?

Answer 8

Your senseless attempt to create new buzz phrases is a flop.

There are no new liberals like there are new conservatives who do not adhere to traditional conservative views.
There is no movement against God - people who are against religion are against institutions and may not believe in God so cannot be against what they don't recognize.
Go learn of what you speak and then come back. Even as a troll you have a lot to learn.

Answer 9

It's a diversionary tactic to try to keep people from noticing that they are just bigots.

Answer 10

See a therapist immediatly