Saturn Girl vs Emma Frost?

Answer 1

Emma cuz not only she's a very powerful and high skilled telepath but she's also very smart (You have to read the arcs she's in to know what I mean). Consinder this, she's able to defeat Rachel the Marvel girl with the extreme power of the pheonix force (Unncany #415 or sth), telepathically. And what's with Phsylocke is a macth with Emma? Please! Justify your answer.

And I don't know how that Saturn girl is going to defeat The White Queen in diamond form..... You need to learn more about her in this form, pal.

Here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emma_Frost

Answer 2

A good question. Let us some parameters. Saturn Girl (classic silver-age), Emma Frost (pre-diamond-body).

Saturn Girl.

Why?

Emma is fast and vicious and Saturn Girl in the old Legion stories basically read minds and used her powers for contact with non-speaking or Alien creatures.

However Saturn Girl came from a planet, a whole planet of telepaths, so she would have more training and know more tricks and moves than Emma ever could.

Plus she was a stone cold fox in a 1960's wholesome way.

Answer 3

I may have to take the fifth on this one, as EITHER of those two hotties would slap me if they read my mind!

Don’t forget that Imra Ardeen was tested as the most powerful telepath on her planet (Titan) whereas Emma is merely the third ranking telepath in the Marvel Universe (after Prof. X and Jean Grey.) On that basis, I believe that Saturn Girl would win.

But let’s assume them equal. They are able to shield their minds from each other. Thus, they reduce to physical combat almost instantly.

I know that for a while Emma Frost was able to transform her body into organic diamond, much as Colossus was able to transform his body into organic steel. They don’t seem to have made much use of this recently, and she may have lost it. But let’s say that she still has it.

Does this make her unbeatable? No! Saturn Girl has her Legion flight ring, and therefore has the mobility advantage. It boils down to, who would make the more sophisticated use of her resources?

If Emma does not put Imra down at the first blow, Imra is sneaky and devious and could defeat her. Here’s how: she would ‘lose’ her flight ring, which Emma would then pounce on, to deprive her ‘victim’ of her movement power. This ruse would work, because Imra’s mind cannot be read.

Here’s the key: the rings are mentally activated…! and Emma has no experience with them! Imra quickly boosts Emma up to an altitude where she can’t breath (not having the automatically activating trans-suit.) If the diamond form confers upon Emma Frost a degree of life support capability, such that she does not have to breathe, Imra Ardeen simply lifts her to a great height—and drops her.

Fond as I am of Miss Frost, I’d like to see her survive that.

13 JAN 07, 0409 hrs, GMT.

Answer 4

Saturn Girl

Answer 5

Depends if you're talking about Saturn Girl (pre-crisis version) or Saturn Girl from that horrible Kids WB version of the Legion?

I used to like the Legion of Super-Heroes comic book series by DC back in the day (pre-Crisis On Infinite Earths), but stopped after the whole Magic Wars nonsense.

Emma Frost is also one of my fave characters in the X books, so.... Hmmmm.... tough call.

I'd pick Emma over Imra (Saturn Girl's real name) on who's sexier, but Imra is more powerful (pre-crisis version).

Answer 6

Would have to go with Saturn Girl. With her training, from her native planet, she is an incredible telepath. That, combined with her LSH training and experience, she would be more than a match for Emma Frost

Answer 7

Emma's not even third actually there's moon dragon and master mind that come back to earth very often and psylocke which was on the same level as Emma frost surpassed her when she got the crimson dawn mark. and even if that went her power have still surpassed Emma . let's face it Emmas not even in sature girls league I don't care how visous you or how you like to cheate if that ohter person figue you out fast enough and is more skiiled thenyou in every way and pshyically stonger. your still tost.

Answer 8

I don't know who saturn girl is, but I have it on good authority that anything with emma frost and another chick involved would end up in hot girl-girl sex.

Answer 9

saturn girl