English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Enterprise Would kick *** for a start the enterprise has sheilds none of the star wars shps do also star wars ships have no transporters or no way of effecting the transporters so the enterprise could beam a torpedo right into the reactor core of the star wars ships blowing them all up easilly allso the enterprise has its defletor which could be used for some type of weapon like they did against the borg maybe so who wins is obvoius but if anyone has other views let me know ?

2007-01-10 05:54:58 · 9 answers · asked by Luke 1701 1 in Entertainment & Music Polls & Surveys

I have thought about this question more and needs rephasing im not saying the enterprise by itself could destroy something like a star destroy even thought it could do alot of damage lets say you have a fleet of star trek ships and a fleet or star wars ships then i was thinking most defuntly the star trek ships would win they have more maneaverbilty and they dont only have photon torpedos they have quatums and many other torpedos also the enterprise and other ships can be fitting out with peregrine federation fighters which would kick tie fighters *** so easy and can someone clear up the fact that in every star wars game ive played the only sheild star wars ships had were the sheild that stop ships flighting into there docking bays i also know about the jedi but isnt it true in the star wars world the jedi are peaceful so wouldnt fight on the evil darthvader and there side same as with chewwy and so on there on the good side so we arent talking about them...

2007-01-13 06:04:35 · update #1

9 answers

i think that the enterprise would win. lets face it, unless jedi actually boarded the enterprise they would not be able to affect it, as seen in episodes 1 & 3 jedi can be trapped by force fields where you can beam them right into space or a star or something, you are wrong however about Star Wars ships having no shields, they do have shields, but not nearly as solid as the shields on the enterprise, if a star destroyer or its tie fighters were firing at the enterprise it would be like bees bouncing off a windshield. all the enterprise would have to do is fire one torpedoe into the bridge of the star destroyer, as seen in episode 6 one A wing crashing into the Bridge of a super star destroyer was all it took. Now the death star is a different story. as long as the enterprise stays out of the path of the main gun it should do okay. In episode 6 enterprise would have had to blow up the sheild generator on Endor, which it could have done from orbit. I dont know how it would have blown up th death star, probably by beaming an explosive war head into the core.
Palapatine couldnt change that or he would have done so in episode 6, and he was one of the more powerful sith, and for the most part jedi are not that powerful

2007-01-16 17:10:44 · answer #1 · answered by zorro1701e 5 · 0 0

You obviously don't know star wars well, star wars ships have shields, thier shields are actually far better than star treks. (the star wars shields are mentioned in almost every movie and book) And they would not be able to beem anything past the shields. Know with that established lets put enteprise NCC 0701 E against a victory class star destroyer. the enterprise has photon torpedos and phasers but a maximum yield of 4 torps and before a brief pause the phasers fire 1-4 at a time. The star destroyer has around 52 turbolaser batteries (turets) 30 proton torpedo lanchers, and 20 regular lasers all of which fire very rapidly. Just between the two ships the enterprise is definatly done. All the star destoyer has to do is taget the enterprises weapons in about 4 places and the enterprise is a sitting duck. With a star destroyer you have to take each turret offline individually. Then if the star destroyer feels like it the can release thier fighters, anout 60 squadrons (12 ships to a squadron) of very fast agile tie fighters, interseptors and bombers, what does the enterprise have, a few slow bulcky shuttle craft. The enterprise doesn't stand a chance.

2007-01-12 11:01:25 · answer #2 · answered by Han Solo 6 · 0 0

Well Enterprise E is advance right? First of all think that Star Wars is in the far past and Star Trek the 23 century and on right?

I believe that Star Wars would win, and this is why:
Remember that Star Trek is more about science and a bit more realistic than the fantasy world of Star Wars Some 'facts' head.
Star Wars: Slave-1:
Main guns: 64000 GW (2 kilotons per shot, 480 rpm firing rate onscreen in AOTC for time-averaged power output rather than peak output)

Star Trek: Enterprise-D
Main phasers: 3.6 GW
Slave:
Asteroid destruction: Jango Fett's seismic charges destroy asteroids in a radius of 5-10 km in AOTC

Star Trek:
Asteroid destruction: according to Riker, it would take the entire photon torpedo payload to destroy a single 5km wide hollow asteroid in "Pegasus". In other words, it would take the entire payload of the Enterprise-D (a capital warship with a crew of a thousand) to equal just one of Jango Fett's seismic charges (a bounty hunter's weapon).

Well as you see if Slave One can do that damage just think what an Imperial Star Destroyer could do, rip those shields apart. Don't get me wrong I love Star Trek because it's more realistic, but in this instance Star Wars has the upper hand.

Finally remember this:
Generally speaking, the sheer scale of the Empire (millions of planets, able to build moon-sized Death Stars) is vastly greater than that of the Federation, so Trekkies try to take the sheer size and numerical advantage of the Empire out of the equation, and simplify matters into straight ship vs ship comparisons. Leaving aside the tacit admission of defeat already implicit in this practice, there are several different popular ways to decide what is and isn't valid evidence...

SORRY to rain so hard on you :( I know you are a fan and you love what you love =D Star Trek still rocks.

2007-01-14 14:41:02 · answer #3 · answered by Alim 3 · 0 0

Sorry, but most Star Wars ships do have shields. Ray shields protect from laser blasts, while deflector shields protect from physical damage. If you watch the movies, many times shields will fail, activate, and be destroyed.

Also, Star Wars may not have teleporters, but they have Jedi that can fool with your mind, make you fight better, along with having lightsabers, which cut through anything. Star Trek has phasers...'nuff said.

Star Wars has Proton Torpedoes (heavy damage) and Concussion Missiles (piercing damage), while Enterprise has photon torpedoes. Star Wars also has starfighters that would harry the Enterprise to death with missle runs and laser blasts, while the Enterprise does not have much fighter defense!

I think Star Wars wins hands down...

Oh, and Star Wars has Chewie, Boba Fett, Vader, Palpatine, and General Grievous...

2007-01-12 04:00:05 · answer #4 · answered by ntcplanters 3 · 1 0

Star Wars.

2007-01-10 06:11:20 · answer #5 · answered by Chris 4 · 1 0

Star Wars.

2007-01-10 06:00:21 · answer #6 · answered by Judas Rabbi 7 · 2 0

The Death Star would kick the Enterprise E butt, if it had one.

2007-01-16 02:20:32 · answer #7 · answered by iamknives64 5 · 0 0

Enterprise,Simply because they always have a solution to everything.

2007-01-10 06:01:37 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

BEAM ME UP SCOTTY THERE IS NO INTELLEGENT LIFE HERE

2007-01-16 06:57:14 · answer #9 · answered by standingbare3 2 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers