What would happen if Brady and Manning switched teams?

Question

Keep this into account: Brady has consistently put up good numbers over 3500 yards every year without Pro Bowl recievers (this year with Reche Caldwell and Jabar Gaffney as his top recievers). Would he put up as prolific numbers as Manning?(although he did have a 4,100 yard season without Pro Bowl recievers).Would he still have the Super Bowls?
Keep this into account: Manning chokes in the big games. Would he be different under a superior coach (Bill Belichick)? Would he have all the Super Bowls Brady has now? Would he still have the high numbers?

Answer 1

The Pats would be worse...not horrible...but a wildcard team probably
The Colts with Tom Brady (as much as I hate the guy) would be unstoppable. He doesn't make the pre-snap adjustments like Peyton, but he makes better decisions during the plays. With that kind of talent around him, Brady would be unstoppable

Answer 2

It probably would make a pretty signifigant difference because each quarterback has his own person on the offense that he will connect with. Just it takes a little time to adjust. Plus Peyton is like a big shot for the Indiana state, but there really isn't anything else. plus like someone said, brady is about short passes and manning is about big plays. i mean manning could use those short passes sometime to burn sometime. Manning gets those TDs quick, but if in the final quarter and he scores and its a tie game and he gives it back to the opposite team then it just allows the other team to at least go for a field goal and win the game. he's all about the scoring and get it over with. and he is very precise with that but come on burn up the clock so the other team does not have time to score. Brady knows how to get the game started. He can take a little time to warm-up but then after that he is on a roll. He is just fired up until the last seconds of the game. He knows how to get those first downs and burn the clock when he needs to, so the opposing team won't get the ball and beat them. But normally by the third quarter they are already easily ahead. All the pats have to do is keep the defense fired up and not to be arrogant and say "oh this game is over" just like what probably happened with romo at the playoff game against the seahawks. But i have to say that both QB's are very efficient, accurate and professional in their own way. So i think that everything should stay the same.

Answer 3

Hey Brady's receivers haven't been chopped liver....Look at Deion Branch....I heard Brady was really sad when he left the patriots.....I was kind of sad for Brady because they should have done everything in their power to keep Branch on the team for Brady.......When it comes to Peyton and Marvin Harrison.....Both are really talented but they have such a great chemistry that I think they have made each other even better......I read a story once where Carson Palmer and Chad Johnson went down to Indy to watch Peyton and Marvin to learn how they did it....... I wonder if the Belichik would give Peyton the type of control that Dungy allows Peyton to have.....Peyton calls alot of his own plays because (no disrespect to Brady intended) Peyton is the best mind in football. He is able to see things that would pass up some QBS.....He seems to notice everything... Yes, he hasn't won a Superbowl YET but doesn't mean he never will.. All the pieces either have to fall into place or you have to be really lucky. Brady didn't win those superbowls all on his own. Yes he was major factor but all cylinders had to be clicking... Just like when Peyton wins his it won't be all on his own.

Answer 4

it may be rediculous because of the fact Brady replaced into there to regulate video games that a great protection stored in examine. Peyton got here to the worst group in the NFL, as does each and every #a million draft %., to hold a desperate group a winning season. it particularly is probable the main mandatory ingredient people forget approximately while they are asserting Peyton chokes. the guy went to a set that chokes. Now their on the best direction. to respond to your question, with a great protection, of direction Peyton might have had a hoop in the previous in his occupation. All Brady did replaced into throw for a hundred and fifty yards and beat between the terrific offenses of all time to renounce the Rams and win a hoop. i think of Peyton could have controlled that, yet returned the question is slightly rediculous. Peyton performed years previously Brady and the Brady ought to not at all have been put in the placement to steer a three-thirteen desperate group to the playoffs with out the help of a protection. He replaced into drafted previous due for a reason. He has been groomed and coached properly. i might say Peyton could no longer have completed from now on perfect because of the fact what number extra jewelry ought to you particularly win? 3 is fairly astounding so which you will no longer particularly say Peyton might have 4 or 5 because of the fact it particularly is merely absurd.

Answer 5

Both teams would suffer, as both QBs are more well adapted to the system they're currently in.

Brady would suffer in Indy as he's used to a more spread-it-around short passing style of game. Indy's receivers are more big-play, breakaway receivers than the routerunners Brady has always been used to. Harrison and Wayne would lose looks and yards.

Peyton would suffer in NE for the same reason; he's always been given receivers as gifted as he is, and he's had a long time to build chemistry between them. Stick him in New England, with their salary cap carousel always moving receivers in and out, and he'd be seeing a lot more drops and picks.

Plus, Dungy has styled his offense around Manning's ability to read the D and audiblize at the line. Belichick is a tightly controlled strategist, and I dont think he'd be willing to give Manning as free a rein to run the no huddle

Answer 6

Manning under belichick wouldnt choke. Also Brady in the colts wouldnt be that much different from Manning since both are great qb's.

Answer 7

The biggest difference would be that the Colts would immediately become a better playoff team and a legit threat for the Super Bowl.

The Patriots, with Manning, would become perennial first round playoff losers.

Answer 8

You assume that its only the quarterback that wins or loses games. I don't think Brady and Manning switching teams would make any difference. You're still stuck with the same defense, the same offensive line, the same special teams and so on.

Answer 9

Pats would still win the Super Bowl

Answer 10

Brady would win, Manning would lose. As to the "better" coach ask the Browns about the "genius." He really isn't that great. He has the best QB in the league so he gets more credit then he deserves. Not a Browns fan either, I am a Steelers fan but I rememeber when the "genius" wasn't.