English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Vladmore?

Arod?

Jeter?

Tom Glavine?

Pedro?

Bonds?

Johnson?

Clemens?

Peddiate?

Reveria?

Mussina?

Willis?

Roy Halladay?

Joe Torre (As Manager)

Donnie Baseball?

Ortiz?

Rameriz? (How do you spell his last name?)

Johan Santana?



Yes, I know many of these are easy ones, just wanna see what other people think,

2007-01-07 10:02:13 · 13 answers · asked by Anonymous in Sports Baseball

13 answers

dude you gotta learn to spell names

vlad- maybe only if he stays healthy

arod- without a doubt as he was one of the best shortstop ever

jeter- no doubt true watchers of him know why

glavine- if he reaches 300 but he really isn't much better than mussina just played for better teams overall (mussina started with baltimore)

pedro- yes he will be like sandy koufax just not as good

bonds- if mcgwire gets in then yes

clemens- shouldn't even be questioned

pettitte- no way he hasn't been as dominate as others just played for an amazing team

rivera- again this shouldn't even be questioned

mussina- problem is that he doesn't have enough wins and his numbers aren't dominate enough to get in without the wins if he gets in then cone and orel should get in

willis- right now no since he is inconsistent

halladay- only if he puts up the same numbers and stays healthy

torre- yes the yankees saved him because he was not as successful before that

donnie- probably not since he hasn't gotten the length and the votes have not been close recently

ortiz- no way not around long enough

manny- definitely hes among the best ever

santana- at this rate nothing is stopping him

2007-01-07 12:27:24 · answer #1 · answered by Under Construction 2 · 1 0

Well first because a player is good does not make him a Hall of Famer. David Ortiz is not Hall worthy, he can hit home runs, but nothing else jumps out at you. Take Yogi Berra and you see he has a HoF career, 3 MVP's, 10 World Series rings, more World Series hits than anyone, caught a perfect game, hit more homers than any catcher until Fisk came along, plus he was a good batter. Johan Santana has put up a few good seasons, but not enough to be in the Hall. Manny Ramirez is definitely going in, he can hit for average sometimes, he is a great batter, and a key contributor to the team he's on. Donnie Baseball should be in, you look at his stats and though they are not incredible, he only played a while, had he not had back problems he could've just retired a few years ago, his career could've been a lot greater than it was, which is saying something. Joe Torre is one of the reasons the Yankees are the Yankees again, he's a fantastic manager, who can perform in the playoffs, plus he's got Rings. Roy Halladay won't go in the Hall, he's had one good season, but he's always injured and he won't be able to put up Hall numbers due to that. Dontrelle Willis is a no-brainer...NO! He had one 20 win season, but he mostly puts up a season that a number 3 or 4 pitcher would put up. Moose maybe. He has a lot of career wins, and a good amount of strikeouts, and a decent ERA. Rivera, not Riviera, will definitely be in. He is one of the big reasons, the Yankees of the mid 90's to mid 2000's teams have done so well. He is the most dominant closer of all time, he posts a low ERA, has four Rings, and he gets K's. Pettitte will have to put up a few more good years before he can be seriously considered. He doesn't have a large amount of wins for as long as he's been playing, and he's not a K machine. Yet he performs quite well in the postseason. Clemens is an easy first ballot Hall of Famer, he has a lot of wins, the second highest amount of strikeouts, and an above average ERA. He also has a cabinet full of awards. Johnson will also be in, his wins are approaching 300, he's probably the best strikeout pitcher of all time (better than the Ryan Express), he has five Cy Young awards, a perfect game, a no-hitter, and a Series MVP and Ring. Bonds will not be in, although he is one of the greatest to play the game (remember in the 90's before 'roids, he could steal, field, hit homers, and post a good average). Until there is proof he never took steroids, he won't be in, he also isn't a performer in the postseason, but he has 8 Gold Gloves, and 7 MVP's. Pedro will probably be in, because he has a good attitude, and he's a good player. He has a few Cy's, a Triple Crown, a World Series ring, and less than ten K's away from 3,000. Glavine will also be in the Hall, there's no doubt in my mind he'll get 300 wins, and he can get strikeouts, post a low ERA, and he owns two Cy Youngs. Jeter will get over 90% of the ballot, he is a fan favorite, a reporter favorite, he is one of the best fielding shortstops, he can hit the longball, a good baserunner, and he puts up a good average. A-Rod will be in because by the end of his career his numbers will be incredible, hopefully sometime he'll move back to SS, where he can win a few more Gold Gloves, he'll have a lot of homers, a lot of hits, and a .290-.315 average, not to mention a few MVP's (2005 won't be his last), and hoepfully a ring. Vlad will also be in, he's a great player, who can occasionally steal, he bombs the ball, and he has a cannon for an arm, he gets a lot of hits, and puts up good OBP and AVG.

2007-01-07 22:22:49 · answer #2 · answered by kblavie 3 · 0 1

Vlad Guerrero- yes: best 5-tool player today

arod- yes: a bad year for this guy is 40 homers and 110 RBIs

jeter- yes: most dependable player under pressure out there

glavine- yes: been consistently near 20 wins his whole career

pedro- yes: when he comes back he'll start winning again

bonds- no: at least he better not; more ounces of steroids and excuses in his blood than home runs he has hit

johnson- yes: dominating his whole career, with or without the mullet

clemens- absolutely: what hasn't he done yet? he's still amazing and he's 43

pettitte- maybe: has hall-of-fame stuff and awesome postseason numbers; otherwise he's just pretty good

rivera- definitely: he's babe ruth as a closer; all he throws is a cutter and no one can hit him

mussina- maybe: he's a lot like pettitte

willis- maybe: it's too early to know... if he keeps pitching the way he is now then definitely

halliday- yes: he's one of the most underrated pitchers in the bigs and people still think he's amazing

torre- yes: he's only one of the best managers in history. When he and Jeter retire, the Yankees will have retired all of their single digit numbers

donnie baseball- maybe: he has good numbers, but nothing really jumps out at you

ortiz- yes: he almost won the mvp two years in a row as a DH

ramirez- yes: he and ortiz are the most devastating 3-4 punch in the history of the game--- just not quite as good as ruth and gehrig

santana- yes: late in the season no one can hit him... he has the sickest slider in baseball

2007-01-11 18:01:43 · answer #3 · answered by Toddles 3 · 0 0

Vladimir Guerrero? If he can stay healthy he will put up the numbers to get him in.

Arod? Sheer numbers will get him in

Jeter? Yes

Tom Glavine? Yes

Pedro? No

Bonds? Yes, but not likely 1st Ballot

Randy? Johnson? Yes

Clemens? Yes, unequivically

Pettite? No

Rivera? Yes

Mussina? If he does it's b/c of the rings

Willis? No

Roy Halladay? No

Joe Torre (As Manager) Yes

Donnie Baseball? No

Ortiz? No

Ramirez? Yes

Johan Santana? If he stays healthy then, Yes

2007-01-07 21:11:43 · answer #4 · answered by Paul D 2 · 0 0

Vladmore? (sic) No

Arod? Yes

Jeter? Yes

Tom Glavine? Yes

Pedro? Yes

Bonds? Yes

Johnson? Yes

Clemens? Yes

Peddiate? (sic) No

Reveria? (sic) Yes

Mussina? No (btw, Mussina doesn't HAVE any rings)

Willis? No

Roy Halladay? No

Joe Torre (As Manager) Yes

Donnie Baseball? No

Ortiz? Maybe, needs to keep it going for a few more years

Rameriz? (sic) (How do you spell his last name?) Probably

Johan Santana? No

2007-01-07 21:11:25 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

Guerrero - no
ARod - Yes
Jeter - Yes
Glavine - Yes
Pedro - Yes
Johnson ( i assume u mean randy) - Yes
Clemens - Yes
Pettitte - No
Rivera - Yes
Mussina - Interesting case.. I could see either way, but i'll say yes
Willis - No
Halladay - Too early to tell, but my gut says yes
Torre - Without a doubt
Mattingly - No
Ortiz - No. Sportswriters do not like dhs, and his career started too late
Ramirez - Best right handed hitter in the last 40 years, Yes
Santana - Yes

2007-01-07 19:02:37 · answer #6 · answered by Vegas777 2 · 0 0

Vladmore- yes
Arod- yes
Jeter- yes
Tom Glavine- as long as he gets 300
Pedro- no
Bonds- yes
Johnson- as long as he gets 300
Clemens- YESSSS
Peddite- no
Reveria- yes
Mussina-no
Willis- eventually maybe....possibly
Roy Halladay- no
Joe Torre - as player and a manager
Donnie Baseball- yes
Ortiz- no
Ramirez- no
Joan Santana- Probably

2007-01-07 18:14:53 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

vlad-yes
Arod-Yes
Jeter-Yes
Tom Glavine-Yes
Pedro-YEs
Bonds-NO
Johnson-Yes
Clemens-Yes
Peddiate-No
ReveriaYes
MussinaYes
Willis-to early to determine
Roy Halladay-to early to determine
Joe Torre -yes
Donnie Baseball -yes
Ortiz-no
Rameriz-no
Johan Santana-to early to determine

2007-01-07 20:40:11 · answer #8 · answered by Michael 3 · 0 0

Vladmore-no
Arod-no
Jeter-yes

2007-01-10 20:24:57 · answer #9 · answered by chrisorrrobinson 2 · 0 0

vlad=y
arod=y
jeter=y
glavine=y
pedro=y
bonds=y
johnson=y
clemens=y
pettite=n
rivera=y
mussina=n
willis=to early to tell
halladay=to early to tell
torre=y
mattingly=not for a long time
ortiz=if he has another 3 years like the past 3 then yes
manny=y
johan=y

2007-01-07 18:25:03 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

fedest.com, questions and answers