Should American citizens who hire,finance and support illegal immigration be considered traitors?

Question

As far as im concerned if your in favor of amnesty and do anything to aid and abed them you have commited treason against the United States of America.

Answer 1

Welcome fellow patriot!

Answer 2

As far as I'm concerned, you have no idea what it means to be an American. Like it or not, we have a capitalist society, which means that business can make a bigger profit from cheap labor.

People that aren't totally brainwashed by the media can see some of the positive traits illegal immigrants have. They're often willing to do the jobs that us "civilized Americans" don't want to do, and they work twice as hard for half the money. Illegal immigrants are practically rebuilding New Orleans, standing hip-deep in toxic $hit water, with no health insurance.

Americans want things built, trash emptied, roads paved, buildings erected, bathrooms cleaned, flooded cities cleaned up, floors mopped, etc., but Americans don't want to do it themselves. So then they pay illegal immigrants to do it, and the Americans whine and complain about them being here.

You can't have it both ways. Either grab a mop and get to work, or stop being so concerned with how others live their life. These "traitors" work longer and harder than you because they didn't have the opportunity to do so where they came from. Some of them are criminals and scum, but the same could be said of some of America's white naturalized citizens.

Answer 3

listed here are my responses on your 5 speaking factors. a million. – no one is against the regulation. unlawful is an adjective for habit, not a man or woman. in case you may connect unlawful to anybody violating a regulation, no remember if federal, state or community, then there are a number of greater unlawful human beings than only the immigrants. 2. – the way I comprehend it, lots of the undocumented immigrants’ toddlers are US voters with the aid of start. So the great numbers being quoted with the aid of public place of work seekers are skewed for sensationalism. An undocumented immigrant would not qualify for public advantages (guidance & emergency care excluded). 3. – This u . s . would not comprehend poverty. What poverty there is could be addressed. The economic equipment in this u . s . is such that anybody who desires to artwork can discover artwork. there is not any excuse for unemployment interior the US right this moment. perhaps there are people who experience above the roles available, yet it incredibly isn't any excuse for unemployment. 4. – it incredibly is is going to you. i won't be able to argue with you in this one. you're marvelous. 5. – considered one of our maximum renown American icons – the Statue of Liberty boasts here words, “supply me your drained, your undesirable, your huddled lots yearning to respire unfastened, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. deliver those, the homeless, tempest-toss to me. I carry my lamp beside the golden door!” How lots greater patriotic, my expensive James, might you have us be?

Answer 4

Treason is a bit harsh. However they are certainly breaking a law. Keep in mind that laws are not necessarily enforced or aren't enforced 100%. Enactment of laws about things is easy. It's the enforcement that trips us up. As you may be aware, all laws aren't necessarily enforced uniformly, as much as we might like to believe they are. And some laws are quite difficult or nearly impossible to enforce and maybe shouldn't have been enacted because they were stupid laws that were impossible to enforce. Successful laws produce wide-spread voluntary compliance and produce the desired result. An example - speed limit laws GENERALLY serve to slow people down to reasonably safe levels although we all know of occasions when these laws are broken.

Answer 5

the problem is not with the number of illegals coming into the country and taking our jobs.

the problem is in the big corporations such as Nike, Coleman....etc. That outsource thousands of jobs to malaysian sweat shops.

what would you call that action? not hiring people in america at all, because you can hire 20 people in another country for the same price as one person in united states.

Answer 6

Look man i myself am an immigrant, but i came here legally, i had a visa to cross overhere and my dad is us born so that made the process a whole lot easier for me. But why give them so much problems than they already have. I wanna tell u this, just let them live here, they are hard working individuals who, in fact do the work that not even a redneck would want to do, they work hard some are even exploited. They are out there working the fields picking fruit and vegetables for you to put in your table, some pick up ur trash, mow ur grass and so forth. Would u want to do this type of job, i dont think so, even since the slave era whites do not want to pick their own fruit, hence the slaves. So in my opinion i think that they should be given the right to become a u.s citizen or permanent resident, at least the ones who have been here for five years or more, I myself am a permanent resident and i admit that i dont want to do a job like those, im looking for higher education, I feel that people should give them a break, because they do the jobs that not a single red wants to do. Dont expect everything to be given to you in a silver platter.

Answer 7

Well, that's the beauty of living in the United States of America...things that you think are traitorous are not considered traitorous to others...same as some of the things you do someone else might be considered traitorous. So just call it a draw and call it a day.

Answer 8

Not treason, perhaps, but I agree that they ought to be punished and deterred more harshly than they are presently. They are contributing directly to a host of social and economic ills, the cost of which all Americans must bear, for their own personal gain. In effect, they are robbing the nation.

Answer 9

I wouldn't take it as far as treason but I think that people/employers who aid them (especially by giving them cash jobs) should be heavily fined.

Answer 10

They certainly are not for the american way of life. This is a republic of laws, not of men so everyone should obey the laws. Traitors, yes.

Answer 11

No, they're just capitalists, businessmen, thats who this country is run by, and that is what it breeds. No surprise here dude. Patriotism and pride? Ha! In a nation that sold millions of dollars worth of flags after 9/11 that were made in Taiwan. Open your eyes.