frank thomas or jim thome?

Question

carrer u duh

Answer 1

Jim Thome hands down. Living in Chicago I have been able to watch both players for years, Thomas with the Sox, and Thome with the Indians and Sox (never caught too many Philly games).

Thomas is a damn good hitter, but a complete and cocky jerk who alienated his teammates and was actually called out by more than a couple. He also was a horrible fielder. Thome on the other hand always seems to say the right thing and I have never heard a teammate say a bad thing about him.

Another common problem is injuries. While Thome has been hurt and missed most of a season with injuries, Thomas is constantly getting hurt.

Hitting wise, you can't go wrong with either one of them, they are both great hitters.

Answer 2

Frank Thomas...we're talking about a guy who in his prime could hit for power AND average. Thome is good but has only hit over .300 3 times compared to 10 by Thomas. Neither can field, they are a virtual push on power. Hopefully both will hit #500 this year. They're both a couple of classy players and if both can stay healthy this year and get #500, both will probably get in the Hall.

Answer 3

Carrer wise- Thomas will go to the Hall Of Fame, Thome not a Hall Of Famer.

Answer 4

Jim thome

Answer 5

Frank Thomas.

Answer 6

thome, hes more consistant than frank thomas. For thome, every years a good year, but frank just came back this year. frank dissapeared for a couple of years, because he didnt hit many homers

Answer 7

All time- Thomas
Right now- Thome

Answer 8

Thomas- 487 HRs, 2 MVPs (1 unanimous), 1 ring, HOF
Thome- 472 HRs, 0 mvps, 0 rings, HOF?
Hands down

Answer 9

thome

Answer 10

thome