Who shoud I draft in my 12 team keeper league Ryan Garko, Lyle Overbay, or Mike Jacobs?

Question

I like Jacobs and Garko because of there upside and they are cheaper than overbay, but I don't know which one is the best player.

Answer 1

Well, young players in a fantasy league are a coin flip, especially those two. I would also drop Overbay for one of those two, which one is up to you. Pick the one that will be easier and more fun for you to keep track of. If you follow National league more pick Jacobs, if American pick Garko.

I can add that Garko will play in the American Central which may have better pitching than the National East.

Answer 2

mike jacobs. lyle overbay's a beast but go w/ jacobs because he's getting better