Is it possible to criticize the actions of the Israeli government and be pro-Semitic?

Answer 1

Of course it is. At the heart of every democracy is the right of every person to criticize the government.

But the term "anti-Semitic" has a specific definition, akin to racism:

"an·ti-Sem·ite –noun a person who discriminates against or is prejudiced or hostile toward Jews.

Random House Unabridged Dictionary"

IMHO, it's possible to not be hostile or prejudiced against all Jews & still have issues with Israel and its government's actions, even to the point of questioning the nation's existence. The label "anti-Semitic" gets thrown around a lot when Israel's actions are criticized. It's akin to calling anyone criticizing Ronald Reagan in the 80s a "Communist", or anyone who criticized George Bush over the last five years a "terrorist sympathizer." It's an inaccurate characterization, the logical equivalent of trying to punch someone with whom you disagree & hope that that wins you the argument.

In response to an earlier poster, all people do have the right to defend themselves. But is the government of Israel defending its people, or is it defending land? We must remember the colonial nature of the creation of Israel. Just something to chew on.

Answer 2

According to Zionists, No. The question is, really, Is it possible to not criticize the Israeli government or to morally turn our backs on the evil that they do? To criticize unrighteousness isn't Anti-semitism even though the Bn'ai Brith or the modern day zealots would have us believe that it is. The truth is independant of race and creed.

Answer 3

Yes. Just like it's possible to criticize the Bush administration and be pro-America. Criticizing the government of Israel (or some actions of that government) is not the same as criticizing the Jewish religion.

Answer 4

Theoretically yes,but of course the moment someone starts criticizing Israel somebody will call him/her anti semite...Just because you criticize the actions of a government does not make you racist...

Answer 5

One of the key components a democracy and free speech, is the right to criticize the government. This is applicable whether it is your country or not. No one appreciates criticism but a true friend (patriot) will advise you to re-evaluate your actions. This is how democracies have evolved thru time.
Of course, I can not pass up the opportunity to slam the Bush/Cheney gang that immediately respond that one is unpatriotic if you dare disagree with their position. They resort to name calling; try to tag you as a "Liberal." Joe McCarthy used "Commie Pinko" in the 1950's.

Answer 6

Yes. The Jewish people and the govt of Isreal are different entities. Plenty of Jewish people criticize the actions of the Israeli govt.

Answer 7

Yes. There are many Jews in Israel (minority thought) who are against the actions of their government, although do still believe in the existence of Israel. Criticizing how Israel acts or reacts does not necessarily implies to deny its existence.

Answer 8

Depends on which actions. If you say that Israel has no right to defend itself then you are anti-Semetic. If you say that the Israeli government should lower its tax rates, spend more on research, raise the minimum wage, etc then that's not anti-Semetic.

Answer 9

Absolutely. No government is perfect. Doing so doesn't make you an anti-Semite.

Calling for Israel's destruction, however, would make you an anti-Semite.

Answer 10

Regretfully, no. It's my people and our lust for money and power has caused all kinds of hell on earth. Our trickery has fooled many countries into hating who we want them to hate. Our lies have launched many a war. Our cowardliness has tricked other countries into fighting battles for us.....but.....that's the way it goes.
Shalom