Tom Brady versus Peyton Manning. Which one is better?

Question

I'm a huuuuuge Brady fan, being that I live in MA, but I'd like to here what others have to say...

Answer 1

WOW, for all you peyton lovers out there, even the ones that spell his name with an "A", i'm here end your joy. I'm going to go right to the facts. Fantasy wise sure easy one Peyton. But the question is which one is better, not which one who puts up the most fantasy points. Tom has 3 Super Bowl rings. Peyton none. When Tom got to the Super Bowl 3 times, he never had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Brandon Stokley, Dallas Clark, or E. James (who is no longer is with them explaining some struggles on offence), Tom's only big name or threat on offence was Deion Branch who is a little under rated but not amazing like Steve Smith. Tom makes his team good, without him they would be nothing. If you really look at the players Tom has had to work with compared to Peyton you can clearly see Peyton should have it better, but it never worked out for him. If you say Peyton doesn't have a defence like Tom then let me tell you last year the Colts defence was probably one of the feared defences in the league or very tough to say the least. And they had E. James too at the time and they still couldn't get it done. Tom Brady will get you a ring, Peyton will get you the (or suppose to) 1# seed, MVP of the league, Most TD, High passing rating, Most passing yds, Pro Bowl WRs and OL and that's about it, maybe media attention too. Look how good Tom is doing this year without his top receivers, playing with decent receivers to say the most, a rookie RB thats trying to get into a groove with an old vet RB thats starting to decline and a defence thats had its injuries here and there but will get you the ball once a game probably. I hope i convinced all you Peyton lovers, if not please show that i'm wrong. If you don't like typing a lot be brief about it then but give me facts. I'm a Ravens fan by the way but I am no hater of great players or teams, just on the days when they face the Ravens

Answer 2

Tom Brady

Answer 3

PEYTON MANNING ALL DAY!! And I am not a Colts fan either. Right now he is leading the NFL with the highest QB rating of 100.9% and 2 of his recievers are in the top 5 for rec yards.

Also, Manning has been only playing 2-3 years more than Brady in the NFL and Manning's all-time stats blow Brady's out of the water.

manning brady
pass/rushTDs 285 145
yds passing 37,304 21,339
career rating 94.3 88.2
INTs 139 78
completions 3,109 1,881

Peytons got brady on rushing as well as fumbles.

stats don't lie

Answer 4

In fantasy probably Manning but in real football definitely Brady.Manning makes a big show of calling his own plays..big whoop hes been surrounded by talent at receivers and running back. Brady has three rings with crap receivers and a barely competent running game.What has Deion Branch done since he left the Patriots for Seattle..not much but drop balls. Hes now an overpaid 3rd receiver while Brady is still putting up quality numbers with receivers like Reche Caldwell?! But Mannings commercials are better than Bradys lol

Answer 5

Tom Brady.

Answer 6

Individualy Manning is way better then Brady, Manning can pass better then any quarterback presently and you always have a chance to win games with him. Manning is better individually as shown by his many records and his almost perfect season. Brady on the other hand is a team player and wins games for you. Brady easily takes over in the 4th quarter and dominates the game, he leads his team to greatness when it counts and thats why he has 3 rings.

Answer 7

seems to me you're leaning in the direction of brady. considering you probably did no longer point out the reality the colts dashing attack replaced into between the greater serious interior the league. could that be organic skill for Manning besides? I nevertheless bypass with Manning. The Patriots have long previous down hill by using fact the 12 months they have been busted cheating. Matt Cassel Stepped in for a Injured Brady and appeared tremendous going 10-6. Says something with reference to the Pats and the team no longer lots the QB. Curtis Painter Stepped in for Manning and blew the sport enormously undesirable. Manning is the greater useful of the two

Answer 8

Peyton Manning.

Tom Brady has a nice, fancy resumee & past but when it comes to who's better TODAY, Peyton Manning is the best QB hands down.

Answer 9

I want Peyton on my Fantasy team. Sorry. I liked Brady on Family Guy.

Answer 10

Good question . . . both are great QBs. Brady is more experienced, but I've gotta go with Peyton Manning.