Is it cheaper to use my computer for guitar effects like fuzz and wah wah if I'm only working in a studio?

Question

I don't perform in public, I just want to create music with my computer. If I want to record from my guitar straight to the computer is it cheaper/better/worse to use some computer program to create guitar effects like fuzz, talkbox, wahwah or should I buy individual pedals like in "the good old days"?

Answer 1

Depends on how much control you want over the end result. The "old fashioned" pedals will give you the ultimate control. If you have a program, such as Cubase or Protools, then you could use the effects on those with acceptable results. I had Cubase and I used a few effects. Were pretty close to the real thing.... I am sure there are gonna be disagreements, but for the money, buy the program and use it. It will pay for itself as you use it, whereas a pedal won't record your music! Good luck from The Duck!

Answer 2

I'd look at an inexpensive (think Line6 or POD) multi-effects unit with amp simulators. Just plugging your guitar into a computer can make it sound horible without any treatment, and the basic tone controls/boost provided by an amplifier greatly enhances your tone.

For about $100 you could get a multi-effects unit, with all the effects and amp simulators that would do everything you want.

For an effect like wah, you may want to buy an inexpensive expression pedal to control the rate and sweep of your wah. The same pedal could be used for other effects (volume, dynamic filter, 'roto-vibe' style sounds) if your unit offers them.

Just be sure that the unit you purchase features an expression-pedal input.

All that for $150.

Answer 3

Just depends on what kind of sound you like. If you're plugging into a direct box, don't worry about pedals. Most recording programs can simulate any solid-state sound you want if you know how to work it. If you're not playing live, then don't worry about a simulator, either.

from experience (and because I love the 70s overdrive sound), the best quality effects tones came from tube amps and Boss pedals, but I doubt you care enough to spend that kind of money. You'll probably need a wah pedal, though. I don't think you can fake that...