Jay Cutler or Carson Palmer?

Question

Do I go with the Rookie Cutler who has been steadily improving, or do I stay with the Veteran who has been a roller coaster ride?

Answer 1

both playing in the same bad conditions palmer is the better QB

Answer 2

Palmer will start Sunday against Denver despite some discomfort in his throwing shoulder. Palmer looked completely frustrated Monday night against a Colts defense that played better than it has been. His receivers never got open and he was sacked four times.

Cutler posted his first pro win as a starter in the Broncos' 37-20 win over the Cardinals on Sunday. Cutler was 21-for-31 for 261 yards with two touchdowns and an interception. He had a 101.7 passer rating and has the Broncos close to reaching the playoffs with two games remaining. Cutler is 48-for-82 for 592 yards with six touchdowns and three interceptions in his three games as a starter. He has improved each game and is starting to become comfortable running the offense and leading the team. Denver Broncos rookie QB Jay Cutler earned his first NFL win Week 15 against the Arizona Cardinals. Cutler completed 21 of 31 passes for 261 yards with two touchdowns and one interception. He threw a 54-yard touchdown pass to WR Javon Walker on the third play from scrimmage and added a 10-yard touchdown pass to WR Rod Smith in the second half of the game.

You should go with Jay Cutler. With a guy improving like that he is a good choice.

Answer 3

No doubt Cutler this is the game were he hits his peak at home vs a poor passing d. Carson has to deal without his best WR Chad Johnson because he will be SHUT DOWN by Champ Bailey. I have both of these QBs and im starting Cutler over Palmer. Take my advice on this and go with the hot rookie.

Answer 4

palmer

Answer 5

Duh, PALMER