Should students be allowed to cheat by getting others to do their homework?

Question

I know there's no way to stop it, but if we just give them the answers, they won't learn how to do it. And the whole learning system is short-circuited.

Answer 1

This question does crop up from time to time. There's a difference between giving someone an answer and explaining a problem.

If someone posts the same type of question over and over, or posts eight or nine questions in a single post, it seems pretty clear they're just looking for someone to do the work for them, and I tend to ignore those.

If someone posts a single question, or a couple of questions of different types, then I treat it as I would in the classroom. I try to explain how the problem is done. Sometimes I'll carry it all the way through to an answer, sometimes I won't - it's something of a judgement call. The point is to show them how a problem of that type works so they can go back to their homework and work the others of that type.

Yes, people use this site to cheat, and I suspect I've helped more than one of them. But I know that people also use this site to get explanations of things that confuse them, explanations they use to understand the topic better - and that, in my opinion, is the whole point of the learning process.

Answer 2

I had a teacher in 7th grade who gave us a 10 question quiz at the start of each class but the answers were all posted in order on a cork board. By the second day or so everyone realized this and would just look up at the answers. By the second week or so everyone knew the answers and didn't need to look anymore. I don't know if that helps with your question because it's not about cheating but it does say that if you tell the people the answer enough times they remember it better than when you make them do the work to find the answer because people are lazy and don't like to do work!

Answer 3

NO homework is suppose to be a way for teachers to know if what they had taught that day was understood. But asking for help is different. Sometimes when you are in class and the teacher explain the work, student tend to think that they understand the work. But when face with the homework they realize that they don't. i think that they should be able to ask someone whether it is a parent or a buddy to assist them. Not do the homework for them but explain the work in a simplier form and may be use a similar example to help them do the work. Then let them do the homework for themselves and review the work with them and be able to show them the correct way if it is wrong. Student also need to learn that they should let there teachers know if the work that was taught was to difficult for them or if they need to spend a little more time on it.

Answer 4

If students get someone else to do their homework for them, the only one they are cheating is themselves. When it comes time for the test, they have to do it on their own. If they can't do it when it's assigned as homework, their chances of acing it on a test are null to zero.
I completely agree that homework help should be just that -- helping a student understand how to solve a problem, not doing it for them, but unfortunately, some people don't seem to recognize the difference -- or maybe they're just happy to show that they know how to get the right answer.

Answer 5

The same people that cheat in school grow up and cheat in the work-world by getting other people to do their work.

The difference is that in the work-world, most are not as willing to do someone else's work... and the cheater is soon exposed.

In school... a cheater may get a better grade than they deserve.
In employment... a cheater will soon lose everything.

So the habit of cheating must NOT be tolerated during the formative learning years.

Answer 6

Well to an extent,it is acceptable. Think that you have your class test of Biology tomorrow,and u have not prepared anything for the test. Also, today u have got a lenghty assignment of Physics,and d submission date is 2moro, what would u do? Also,if students outsource homework to others, but in that time they study another subject sincerely then no problem. Also, a regular class test should be taken in all subjects,so that u can know the students knowledge who didn't do their homework.

Answer 7

I don't think it's really bad if they learn something. I knew a fellow who paid people to take his chem exams including the final. He flunked out the next term. I usually make crib notes and it ingrains the essentials in me, and I don't need them . Maybe it's a security blanket for me. The only ones they're really cheating are themselves.

Answer 8

No, students should not get others to do their homework. They are hurting themselves because they are not learning the material and it is going to make their life harder later on down the road. Just suck it up and do it.

Answer 9

Absolutely Not, when they allow someone else to do their homework they are only cheating themselves of the learining experience they will need to take the exams in that class plus it will also hurt them in life after school.

Answer 10

Hmmm . . .i've got no longer studied all of garwy's solutions, yet i understand that I even have enjoyed examining a pair of them. I observed yet another positioned up this week with a link to a rant internet site approximately garwy, addressing the ulterior motives which you look to hint at. If, like that poster, you suspect him to be a predator, that's an fullyyt diverse project. I see the cheating project as extra gray than you do. i've got analyzed many poems published, written through Y!A poets and through in call for poets. I try this when I benefit from the poem, or see something diverse from the solutions. till now I positioned up, I generally look at the asker's profile. in the event that they have a string of questions, I generally do no longer answer. in the event that they have a mixture of q and a, i'd put in my 2 cents. i've got additionally seen a great type of questions asking something like, "What do the final 2 lines of this poem advise? i don't get it," with a great type of responses to "Do your guy or woman homework." i detect that intense. My poetry instructor in HS replaced into additionally my grammar instructor. She replaced into very stable with grammar, yet she hated poetry (sure, she instructed us) and easily risk-free it because of the fact of state regs. i did no longer like poetry for numerous years after HS. i think of most of the reason being it replaced into taught as gobbledygook. i like examining the responses on right here, and that i'm no longer a pupil anymore. when I first began examining poetry criticism in college, it did no longer make me lazy. on the different, it have been given me excited approximately something that I had written off. i'm going to bear in strategies different's responses on right here. i do no longer decide directly to do somebody's homework, yet this internet site does no longer be as relaxing if it have been in basic terms a author's group, examining one yet another's paintings.