If jews realy think that parts of Palastine belonged to them 3000y ago,why did they wait so long to claim it?!

Question

If the jews claim that they have "ancient" rights in palastine from 3000 years ago,why they never tried to fight for it all this time(3000y)!!!
R they cowards that they didnt even try to fight for their rights(if they have any)?
why they never tried to go back to their !!"promised land"!! and waited 3000 YEARS!!!until others(UK) did the fighting for them and gave it to them ???
in my opinion If they where COWARDS to fight for their rights then they dont deserve it!!!
What do u think?

Answer 1

Jews were been scattered across Europe from 70CE through 1948, yet there was always a Jewish presence in the Holy Land. They lacked the money, arms, and political support of the many landlords in the area (Ottomans, Byzantines, etc.) Only the UK even offered to recreate the Jewish Homeland there.

I think your generalizations are very bigoted.

Answer 2

Actually, they did. The Maccabee Revolution reclaimed the land and purified the Temple. (Hence Hannukah.) Everything was going pretty well until about 70AD when the Romans sacked Jerusalem and destroyed the temple. They put most of the Jews into slavery and distributed them around the Empire. For the next several thousand years they were trapped. However in the 600's the Jews supported the Muslim invasion of Jerusalem on the grounds that they would be allowed to rebuild the Temple. For a short while, they did have a small structure on top of the Temple Mount, until the local Calif changed his mind and tore it down. Then he went after the Church of the Holy Selpulchre and the Christians came down to take it back. You had 400 years of Crusades - and that certainly wasn't a good time to try and get it back. Then the Age of Enlightenment came along and persecution of Jews abated in Europe. America was settled and for many Jews, America was a gift from God - a land where you could worship anyone you wanted, any way you wanted, and nobody could legally persecute you. But once Hitler made Europe into a living Hell for the Jews, they decided it was time to re-establish the Jewish homeland. Still more Jews live in America than anywhere else in the world.

And it's closer to 4,500 years actually. The first Jewish settlements in what is now Jerusalem date back to about 2,500 BCE.

Answer 3

To begin with it was 2 thousand years and the Romans invaded Israel. Than when the empire fell radical Muslims took over the holy land and the Jews never real abandoned it there some either converted to to Islam or stayed under ground in terms. But Israel was founded 3000 before Islam even started and the poor Jews have been kicked out of every land they've ever had and during ww2 is when we gave Israel nation recognition for Holocaust survivor's to repopulate.And Israel is was of the strongest nation's in the world and they will show there assume might before the end.

Answer 4

Wow, that's the most twisted version of Jewish history I've ever seen.

First, they did build Israel, they founded Jerusalem, etc. and they have been living in that area for 1000's of years. But they've never been a populous peoples compared to the invaders, and thus were constantly invaded. Romans, Muslims, Crusaders, British, etc.

But they have constantly inhabited there for millenia, and had been seeking a refounding of Israel for a very long time. Fight? Yes, they fought. They had terrorists of their own fighting British rule.

Get a clue and stop the hate.

Answer 5

That was established by the UN after WWII.
Lot's of jews believe that the messiah has to come first before their state could be established. There's a difference between Zionism and Judaism.

Answer 6

interior the 1800's, numerous persons interior the U. S. and Canada purely settled on vacant land and geared up a house there; i do no longer bear in mind each and every person objecting. The Tanach extremely states that Israel belongs to the Jewish human beings, and in certainty the land that at the instant makes up contemporary-day Israel is a fraction of the area that G-d promised to the Jews. subsequently, we've each and every suitable to declare that it particularly is ours.

Answer 7

Why didn't they claim it? Well there were a few things that got in the way, like being persecuted by the Romans, persecuted by the Persians, subjected to the tortures of the Inquisition, gassed during the Holocaust. You know, little things like that.

Cowards? You are an idiot!!!!!!!

Answer 8

I dont know that I would cll them cowards, but it does seem absurd that you can return to an ancient home land with an army and evict by force the inhabientents, and get immeadite recognition by the rest of the world

Answer 9

With the blind blindly following the blind .
At loss with the betrayal of Judas one of the dirty dozen with ghostly kitchen's ghost stories and ghostly modern history of failures and horrors of the past from the graveyards in planet of apes.
On the non-existence rights of original descendant in planet of apes..
The mess was created by king midas with the golden touch and withered hands with ghostly stories on non-existence rights of original descendant that those young monkeys fall for it in planet of apes.
At loss king midas created modernisation with imports from advancing countires had been selling ghost stories to the young ones on success of ghostly kitchen's ghost stories in making a monkey out of all those children living in misery in planet of apes.
At loss and blurr on why a sudden rise of a "bad moon rising " in planet of apes.
At loss and blurr king midas is the grave digger who kick the butts of our creator for thirty pieces of silver in planet of apes.
While poor old Saddam at loss and blurr on what went wrong out there in planet of apes.
Will nail Judas to the cross when the time comes.
When the missing x-files in hand with all those landmarks out there in planet of apes.

Answer 10

dont they think that if they had Gods favor that he would have given thier enemies into thier hands already. in bible times it only took days, minutes or just moments.

obviously they do not have Gods backing. they turned thier back on him one to many times and now they are no longer his chosen people.