English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Its is kind of ridiculous..There is insurmountable evidence to the otherwise. However, is it true that jews tricked other fellow jews into the gas chambers in order to save their own lives? was that why it was so repulsive? I read that that was one of the points of the conference. I never heard of that. But upon further study, it seems that it is true--that most of the people that operated the daily functions of the concentrations camps to kill and belie jews, were germans jews doing it out of fear of the nazi germans.

However, this scenario is quite disturbing and disgusting---it is repulsive beyond beleif---that a people would trick their own, for themselves--and why would the germans set it up like that?

my question is, if this is true, then who implemented this? the germans, or jews who catered to the germans to get out of there, and volunteered to kill their own? This is my question.

2006-12-12 10:39:11 · 7 answers · asked by Anonymous in Arts & Humanities History

my bad---I just read wikipedia and said that most of the people in the holocaust were jewish and second, that it was mainly german military and gov that oppressed the citizens of the camps--however, I am still reading on it, I am not entirely sure.

2006-12-12 11:08:36 · update #1

growler...I don't debate you on that one---If I were given a choice to save my family...I would open the gas chamber door and smile at YOU as you went by as well.

But the IDEA and CONCEPT of it is repulsive. I want to know if it is true, I am still researching and what was the set up of it.

2006-12-12 11:21:32 · update #2

I made up the scenario in my head...and in all honest... I would definitely do it to save my own life---if I were young. I would most probably do it.

But its besides the point---I was not dissing on jews---But the IDEA of it, or whether it actually happened. If it did, its the germans fault--but I wondered (1) the repulsiveness of the concept (2) because I originally thought only germans were allowed to escort anybody in the camp--- It appears some jews may have helped, but very few--most were military guys.

just read the wikipedia so you get informed--I didn't know much about the holocaust---so when I saw it in the news, I researched.

Here is the site so you can get informed, it helped me:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust

2006-12-12 11:39:40 · update #3

7 answers

Gawd, are you kidding? What nonsense. People spread crap like this out of ignorance, stupidity and a desire to cover-up their own sick offenses.

2006-12-12 10:44:35 · answer #1 · answered by marklemoore 6 · 1 2

I understand your question.. I don't know who implement this Probably Hans Himmler himself, but from what my uncle says..(he help liberate a death camp) the prisoners didn't have much of a choice..and if i could save my own children id hold the door for you as you went to the gas chamber and Id smile as you passed so you cant blame someone for trying to save there own skin. As for the Lunatic leader of that piss ant country of Iran you need to contemplate the mentality of the fascist Muslim ..there is no logical thinking. they hate everyone who isn't Muslim and they cant understand why. the majority aren't educated and the select few (leaders)are very educated.. take a look back in history..It happened with Christians..the crusades..the Inquisition all those things..the masses uneducated and the few very..

2006-12-12 18:53:27 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

Yes, they did the work there, but they did not drop the Cyclon-B cannisters. That was done by the German SS. They did not trick the other jews. They were, under pain of death, prohibited from talking to them until they had been "processed". A few were always saved to replace dead prisoners and for killed workers in the slave factories. Even then, the work was only temporary. Sooner or later they took the trip to the showers or were shot.

2006-12-12 18:48:46 · answer #3 · answered by Sophist 7 · 2 1

If the intent of the conference and its participants is to discredit any proof presented, this is mean-spirited and useless to argue against. If they don't invite or encourage any real dialogue or study, then you can tell it is just a political ploy to organize and empower those who believe the same viewpoint instead of seeking real truth.

However, if true proof is sought, why not give them what they seek? Even Jesus was glad to provide proof, if it took physically touching and examining the wound in his side in order to believe. Some people require more proof, and also forgiveness of their doubt, disbelief or denial, before they can receive and accept the truth. God sometimes allows this in order to motivate us to establish proof in a more concrete way, such as with science.

As for the Jewish Holocaust, once the mob mentality gains momentum, there is no justification for the type of madness that can ensue. The fear of death, the fear of mayhem and chaos in the streets that was rampant in Germany after the first World War, where the economy was destroyed and people were starving and helpless to protect themselves against mobs -- all these elements led to the rise of Hitler, and once he set the wheels in motion, people followed whether they wanted to or not, similar to how fundamental Islamic extremists will take over a country and force people to fall in line or be killed if they revolt.

I see both the victims and oppressors as common human beings caught in a destructive situation where they felt compelled to kill in order to survive; I don't see it so much in terms of Jewish or German people but a tragedy in history that has affected all humanity.

2006-12-12 19:03:26 · answer #4 · answered by emilynghiem 5 · 0 2

It's all a bunch of politics and religion. Yes, Hitler killed Jews. Yes, some people think the Zionists are out to get them. Yes, others think Islam is out to rule the world. Even more still think the US is taking over by force, and Japan is taking over economically. It's the same thing with different words. Divide and conquer.

2006-12-12 18:44:01 · answer #5 · answered by Dognose0 2 · 2 1

Do not believe anything that the president of iran says. I would say there is about a 50% chance we or Israel will nuke them within 2 years. This may have to be done. Not kidding either.

2006-12-12 18:43:54 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 0 2

It just shows what kind of idiots we have to deal with.

2006-12-12 18:41:29 · answer #7 · answered by festeringhump 4 · 0 2

fedest.com, questions and answers