If David Carr was Black...Would He Still Be STARTER QB TODAY?

Question

Even though this is totally hypothetical.... I know in my heart that this boy should be benched.... he is mediocre at best! (Your Answers Please.)

Talent....What is Carr's Talent?...the Long Throw or Pass Right? Well ...We aren't seeing that develop in 4-5 yrs....Would a Black QB be able to have this MUCH TOLERANCE?

Dunn...you have a point....but C' mon.... you can place this blame on everybody else but the QB? This dude is NOT a PLAYMAKER! Texans Defense is actually descent when they are not on the field every 3 minutes! LOL Car has some WR's WASSUP?

Answer 1

Man this is a deep question....

Ima say no. If he were black they would call into question his mobility. Im just being honest. He shouldnt start b/c he's bad, and honestly , I think if he were black he wouldnt have been resigned.

B4 i get toasted on this, Daunte Culpepper, and Aaron Brooks are much better Qb's and they have been either traded or cut. Good Question.

I just read one of the answers regarding Vick...Are you kidding me?
David Carr will never be a Mike Vick. How many playoffs has david been to? How many probowls has david been to?

Please dont insult our intelligence comparing him to vick

Answer 2

Hey Huey - the answer is yes. David Carr was handled wrong by my home team he should have walked the sideline for 2 years before becoming starter;then thay really screwed up by not choosing Reggie Bush. They have no offense, only 1 real receiving threat - Johnson and he's always faces double coverage. The opposing defense always knows what their going to do with no running game. He's a QB that hands off or passes, that's fine New Orleans improved with Bush, the Texans did nothing to improve their offense and NOW Carr has no confidence, so the bad times will continue until he gets his confidence back.

Answer 3

See this is why my people will never get anywhere..... my people..... Anyway, yes if David Carr was black he would still be the starter. Why? You might ask, because Carr is NOT mediocre at best, his team not including about five other players are mediocre at best!! David Carr's offensive line is mediocre at best!! The running game is mediocre at best!! The defensive side of the ball mediocre!! Coaching......do you see where I'm going with this? Without effective blocking or, a running game that can take the pressure off, or an effective defense everything falls on the shoulders of Carr. One man can't do it all, contrary to popluar belief, Ole' dave just needs some help. H-Town, BABY!!!

Answer 4

Considering the offensive line of the Texans is as strong as a wetnap, I don't think it really matters what race Carr was. He doesn't have an offense good enough to support him.

Quit asking unnecessary race questions and stick to the talent levels of the players.

Answer 5

he likely would
houston, once the example of a climbing expansion team ready to take on the big boys, screwed it all up the last two years.
they're back to 2002 level....... this team is falling apart
david carr has potential... it's the team around him
remember the talk about harrington being a bust in detroit?
texans, would you like to trade that draft pick for reggie bush or vince young?

Answer 6

I presume your question is a dig at the Texans for not drafting VY? I think he would still be the starter, considering how much they have invested in him, and the fact that his play this season has been an improvement over previous years.

Answer 7

If he was black he would suck just as bad......he could probly run faster....

Answer 8

If he was black - would you be asking this question?

Answer 9

yes o racist one, just look at vick. he sucks but hes still playing.