Do you think Pisces are secretive people?

Question

Most of my Pisces friends are private people. They will only tell people things if they trust them. And once you break their trust, they will cut you off their 'trusted people' list forever. Why are Pisces like that?

Answer 1

I am a pisces and yes i am secretive. I do not want everybody knowing all my business because it is my business. I find thats how rumors and lies start when people start telling their business. I will only tell secrets to certain family members and thats it. And yes i have cut many friends out of my life because they have betrayed my trust and that is dear to me. If the trust is broken then honesty is out as well then there is no relationship. I would rather cut someone out of my life than have to constantly wonder will they betray me again. So if your asking this question you must have broken a pisces trust and that d@mn near impossible to gain back.

Answer 2

As a pisces I would have to say that I do not believe that secretive is a good word to describe your freind's behavior. Pisces are very intuitve people, meaning that they can sense when and where they are needed. We are also very nuturing and so they just step in and do whatever they feel needs to be done for those that we love. She could also be too proud, or maybe your friend feels that this is something that she would do for you without thinking twice or whining about not recieving a thank you. I do not think that Pisces are conniving...we are complicated.

Answer 3

Im a pisces and I am a secretive person,I only tell secrets to peope that arent a big deal because we are sometimes afraid of people thoughts or feeling or most likely that something will start.

Answer 4

Pisces people are not secretive at all, but place a high value on trust and personal values. This is why we will cut a person out of our lives for betraying our trust - because once we let you in it leaves us vulnerable to be hurt and if you use that power to hurt us, we don't forget it. It is a self protective mechanism. We love deeper and are more sensitive than all the other signs, which makes us creative, loving and nurturing souls. I wonder why other signs like to betray us like they do.

Answer 5

I'm an Pisces and I'm like that, trust is everything to me. I think it has alot to do with our intelligence and the loyalty that goes with it.

I have gotten rid of alot of friends in my life because I found out I couldn't trust them, without trust there is nothing.

We are secretive until we feel we can trust someone, I test people myself by telling them something that doesn't play a big role in my life and see how they deal with that first.

Answer 6

It's just typical for that sign. I do the same thing. Except I usually like to get revenge which is unusual for a Pisces.

Answer 7

I'm a Pisces and I'm secretive why i dint know i just am.

Answer 8

im a pisces too. hell yeah were secretive! If i ever feel like youve just betrade i just... its over nothing u can say or do that will want me to give u a second chance! so be careful with your friends! b/c if you ever betrade them they wont let u back in into there life

Answer 9

we can hold a grudge forever if we feel in anyway slighted or God forbid..someone break our trust in them.
trust is sacred to a pisces. whether it be for a cause,a mate or a friendship..we insist on absolute loyalty.
we think the whole world should be run on trust and a firm handshake.

Answer 10

Pisces, like Cancer and Scorpio, are water signs which are considered emotional. Water signs are careful to guard their emotions, as they instinctively know it could be used to hurt them.