Who has had the best first year among the three great draft picks: Reggie Bush, Matt Leinart, or Vince Young?

Question

And will that person be the rookie of the year in the NFL? If not one of them who do you think should be the rookie of the year this year?

Oh yeah, I almost forgot:

Texas 41, USC 38

John

I can't deny that the Saints are winning, but Bush has only gained 30 yards per game. That's very low production for the NFL. I know he had 4 TDs last week, but he still had only about 30 yards on the ground. That doesn't seem like a great year or Rookie Of The Year caliber.

Answer 1

Well statistically, I'd say Leinart. He has more yards and a better rating than Vince Young.

But out of these 3, I'd say Young. He has a terrible offensive line and less than spectacular receivers and backs. But, he has more TD's than Leinart. So he is doing more with less.

Bush is doing good, but he's only had 1 good performance. Young has already made 2 4th quarter combacks including the spectacular one against the NY Giants. The Titans couldn't muster a win without him and now they have like 6 with him.

I think rookie of the year though should go to Marques Colston. He is in the top 10 of a lot of receiving categories even though he has missed 2 games. The receiving core and Drew Brees are the reasons why the Saints are so good, not Bush.

Answer 2

I think Bush by far

Leinart is now the team leader and Young is playing well and is also a leader but no way is Bush not the rookie of the year in my mind.

Bush made all his money back in merch and ticket sales and he is a saviour of a franchise. He definitely has the yards and now the TDs and he is dangerous on every play.

All the stars have aligned now in NOrleans with Bush, Brees and heck Colston is a rookie from HOFSTRA who is amazing.

Gotta go with Bush and the Saints. What luck that Houston flubbed the #1 pick!

In the long run all three may be awesome but statistically and socially Bush is best right now. It would be closer if Young or Leinarts teams were playoff bound.

Answer 3

It's between Reggie and Vince. I'm telling ya, those mobile quarterbacks are going to be the quarterbacks of the future. But Reggie Bush has done so many great things in New Orleans, so it's going to be a hard call.

Answer 4

Reggie Bush of course than vince young and matt leinart any time there is a waiting list to get reggies jersey you know who is really doing it

Answer 5

Reggie Bush of the New Orleans Saints. Between him and Drew they have brought the Saints to life.

Answer 6

Vince young , out of them yea i think he would

Answer 7

VINCE YOUNG

Answer 8

young.