Harry Potter being a Horcrux and other theroys?

Question

Ok i think that HP is a horcrux 'Niether can live while the other survies' semms to be a clue to why LV would want to Kill HP. Maybe LV had something of Godric Griffindors when he was in the Potter;s house about to perform The Killing Curse. But the spell backfired and destroyed the last horcrux, LORD VOLDERMORT HIMSELF! But with the magic of the other horcruxs still in play, he was not killed. Yes i know that in The Half Blood prince, Dumbledore said that LV was the last soul they must attack, and that is y my theory makes sense! Ok now onto my other theory, the Death Of Proffesser Dumbledore. i think that PD was a pheonix animagas and is reborn in the 7th book since pheonixs rebirth a little after they die. Or Snape didnt really use Avada Kedavra on PD, but instead PD took the Draught of Living Death, then in the 7th book, Snape or Harry will find this out and shove a Bezoar down his throught. Also, Ginny will go with Harry even though they broke up. Feed back welcome. 10 points to best answer

Answer 1

I have thought this about PD too. Actually, I am pretty sure, because at the funeral he was burnt in flames, and you know Phoenixes die and are reborn in flames. Plus, a powerful wizard like D. must have been an animagus, and what else could he be other than a Phoenix? The only thing that worries me is that I have shared this idea through the internet, and it seems many people have thought the same, so I am worried that Joan Rowling might change it because the surprise is no longer a surprise, but expected. Also, I am sure that Snape had arranged everything with Dumbledore, because Dumbledore was not an old fool to trust Snape. I believe Snape was in love with Lily Potter, and this is the reason he hates James Potter, and he hated Voldemort after he killed Lilly. We have a hint about that because Lilly was good at potions, just like Snape, so perhaps they even dated!
About your first assumption about the horcrux, I think there is a problem: Voldemort doesn't want to destroy his horcruxes, it is those that keep him alive, so if Harry was a Horcrux Voldemort would try to keep him alive, not kill him.

Answer 2

I Just dont get the 'Harry is a Horcrux' theory. Remember how mad Voldemort got when he realised that the diary of Tom Riddle was destroyed? His Horcruxes are essential in keeping him alive. If Harry really is a Horcrux then why is he always trying to kill him. If the theory is true then it would mean that after killing Harry, Voldemort will be closer to death.We all know that Voldemort wants to be immortal so why would he wanna do that?

Answer 3

I hate the Harry is a Horcrux theory. It makes no sense whatsoever. Why would Voldie wanna make harry a horcrux? What's the point in putting a part of your soul into a 1 yr old whom you are "prophesized" to kill (since that's what Voldie thought he had to do according to the partial prophecy Snape heard)

JK likes to repeat herself when something is important. And I remember there being at least 2 or 3 mentions of "cannot bring back the dead" once you've bitten the big one, you're out for good. So that's my opinion on Dumby coming back.

Snape losing all sense of self and control after he did it, is to me a marker that it was real. Dumby "pleaded" with Snape... but not for his life. Dumby was asking Snape to kill him, to go through with it and that's why he had so much hatred in his face and when he faced Harry at the end, why he went nuts.

I do agree with you on Ginny going with Harry, Ron and Hermy after the wedding to find the rest of the Horcruxes.

Answer 4

Character Information We will find out something "incredibly important" about Lily Potter We will find out who R.A.B. is We will discover more about Dumbledore's past We will discover where Snape's loyalties lie. Something will be revealed about Petunia Dursley, although it will not be that she is a Squib Viktor Krum will return (World Book Day, 2004 interview) We will see a reappearance of Dolores Umbridge - "It's too much fun to torture her not to have another little bit more before I finish." (MuggleNet/Leaky Interview) JKR has said, "There is a character who does manage, in desperate circumstances, to do magic quite late in life, but that is very rare..." Plot Information Harry will face Voldemort for the final time Harry will be attempting to find and destroy Voldemort’s remaining Horcruxes Harry will return to the Dursleys' during the school vacation, but the magical protection Dumbledore arranged will expire on his 17th birthday when he comes of age Harry will visit Godric's Hollow There will be a reappearance of the two-way mirror We will see the wedding of Fleur and Bill Weasley The fact that Harry "has his mother's eyes" will prove to be an important plot point At least one character will die Other The last word is expected to be "scar," but may change We will finally learn the full reason why some people become ghosts when they die and others don't The final chapter, which has already been written, will detail what happens to the characters that survive There will be no more Quidditch matches

Answer 5

i doubt Harry is a Horcrux. i have my own reasons for believing in so.

its a little too obvious for JK Rowling to make him a Horcrux because we can assume that he will take his life if it means for Voldemort to be killed.

Answer 6

I don't think HP is a horcrux, but I do think PD is alive. Check out my website it is full of HP theories.

http://rpccstudent.tripod.com/