If you had to choose between Brady and Manning who you would pick and why ?

Question

In one side Brady with 3 rings, the experience and the madurity and in the other side Manning with the precission, stats and speed to throw. The reality is that Vinatieri had gave the Patriots the titles and the Colt´s ex kicker has lost the important games. Now with Vinatieri they have lost games too but he´s much better. Just imagine one of them on your team or in another team who would be better and give them the victory ?

Answer 1

Manning is by far the better QB, and it irks me that people still debate this issue. The success that Brady has had reflects how good his team is as a whole. I'm not saying Brady isn't a good QB, but there are at least 5 other QBs in the league today that could have accomplished the same success had they played for the Patriots. Peyton, along with a few talented skill position players (especially Harrison) has carried the Colts to victory more times than any other team in recent years. I say carried because he has done this with lackluster performance from the Defensive and Special Teams units. The lack of success in the post-season is a reflection of these deficiencies, not some emotional block on Peyton's part. Brady has the benefit of Defensive and Special Teams units that put him into position to win. His success is their success and vice versa, which is how teams sports should be.

In short, gimmie Peyton Manning, but also give me a Patriots caliber Defense and a clutch kicker like Vinatieri. The Colts are halfway there.

Answer 2

They are both outstanding quarterbacks, the best in the league. They are right up there with Montana, Elway, & Marino. Manning is a great leader with a lot of football knowledge. Brady knows how to get the job done and win. I think Manning tries to do too much and sometimes he's overwhelmed, Brady knows how to stop over-analyzing and play ball.

Answer 3

Honeslty I dont think Brady is that good the only real reason that he has 3 rings is look at the Pats Defense and there Recieving core and I have to take Manning even though he had probably the best recieving core in the leauge but in clutch situations I would rather have Manning

Answer 4

Me for who i am i would say Payton i mean look at dat mann arm and he got accuracy but hes just slow in running so is brady i know Brady got those rings but if u look at who will end up in the hall of fame i would pick Payton on my team he is a team leader so is brady but payton will keep his head and lead the team to a victory

Answer 5

the hard question, you have the standard season champ in manning, yet on the different hand you have the playoff champ in Brady. precise now i might say Brady not for the undeniable fact that he has 3 rings (however i might desire to quit there) yet quite he has shown he may well be a brilliant passer with susceptible aims. as quickly as I see Manning appearing without the likes of reggie wayne and Marvin Harrison then i might supply him the %..

Answer 6

I would have to say Brady for the following reason: He has lost receivers left and right and continues to play at a high level, while Manning has had pro bowl receivers around him during his entire career.

Answer 7

We have played both, and I think Manning is an egg head but does not have emotional intelligence when he finds that his chart do not match up to his plays. Brady is too emotional and stiil is concerned about his draft status -- because he was not a first rounder.

But in a crunch-----Brady..He is the real thinker, and he is so patient. I think he is motivated when people tell him he can't do it.

Answer 8

Brady, not only is he the real winner, but i just don't care for Manning.

Answer 9

Without a doubt...Brady is a proven winner.

Answer 10

regular season: manning.
playoffs: brady