What do you thing of Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

He's the best QB in the league. The main reason he hasn't won any Super Bowls is their defense is atrocious. If the Colts and Patriots swapped defenses, he'd have more Super Bowl wins than Tom Brady. He's a smart QB. He's allowed to audible because he's so good at reading defenses.

Answer 2

Love Peyton. Hes half QB and half coach. I don't normally like QBS that just pass in the pocket but I make an exception for Peyton. Hes a treat to watch. The guy just has an amazing football mind. I remember a couple of games ago he saw something in the backfield. He motioned Marvin Harrison over and they had a quick pow wow. Next play he strikes to Marvin for a TD. I love how passionate he seems about the game. I think hes a real character guy and I love his credit card commercials. I'm tired of hearing all the comments like Peyton is great but....blah blah.......I hope they get to the Superbowl and win to shut all those annoying media people up. ANd to curiousguy. If you want to blame anybody for Peyton's comment blame the media. They are constantly trying to trip those guys up to say something that they can create a little drama over.

Answer 3

Top 3 QB in football....maybe. However, ....he's overated. The media loves the guy and he can do no wrong. But his playoff performances are horrendous. He may go down as the best REGULAR SEASON QB....whoopdeedoo. At the end of the day, you need your QB to be clutch in big games, not choke. And you can't say he hasnt won the Superbowl cuz of his defense. For 2 reasons.....there is a reason they dont have great defensive players....cuz they spend all their money on the offensive side. Noone comes close to the Colts in this dept. They expect their offense to outscore the opposing offense. And so thats why they surround Peyton with talented players at the skill positions. If you go back and look at the stats though, their defense has actually done BETTER in the playoffs than the regular season and it is the Colts offense that has failed....and more specifically, Peyton that has failed. His QB rating in their playoff losses is RIDICULOUSLY bad.

and Peyton is NOT better than Marino. Marino improvised much better and had much much worse players at the skill positions to work with and had no running game. You dont think Marino wouldve won one of those years with guys like Edge, Harrison, and Wayne around him?

Right now I'd say the best qbs are Brady, Mcnabb, and Peyton. I actually think Palmer can be a better QB than Peyton, if he gets a little more consistent.

Answer 4

This is coming from a Patriots fan... Peyton's great, the way he controls the offense.. its amazing to watch at times- but the Colts just dont have the defense, and thats what their lacking.. If they had a better defense, there would be no stopping them.

Answer 5

Peyton Mainning is over ratted. I mean i live in Cincinnati and i think that Carson Palmer is better than him. The only reason Peyton is good is because his front line is ammazing.

Answer 6

A very great QB but also very overrated who get on my nerves. It's always Manning Manning as though nobody else on the freaking team matters.

Answer 7

Great QB its a shame he will never get a super bowl he needs to have a team with a Defence I mean when he has to put up the points he does week after week he a tired man come playoffs it a damn shame his team cant finish when it counts

Answer 8

Great quaterback. I hope he wins a Super Bowl because he is being seen as this eras Dan Marino, but I think he is way better because of his leadership skills. The Colts just need to continue getting better on the defensive side of the ball.

Answer 9

peyton manning is one hot QB!

Answer 10

I think he's adorable. And as far as his QB skills I have a lot of respect for a man who can take charge on the field. He's a decent player.