Would you prefer to watch the filmed version of a novel before or after reading the written version? Why?

Answer 1

I'd read the novel first before watching the movie cos the movie's usually disappointing compared to the novel, eg: The Da Vinci Code, A Series of Unfortunate Events, Memoirs of a Geisha... thank god I read the books before watching them on the big screen.

Answer 2

Often when I see the filmed version after the book, it's disappointing. It's tough for films to capture all the nuances and color that the book evokes in my mind. Some good books-to-film include the Lord of the Rings and the Harry Potter books. Some awful books-to-film include the Steve Martin version of Cheaper By The Dozen. They borrowed the title then used none of the book.
Sometimes I see the movie first and then want to read the book to get the whole story. Right now I've borrowed a copy of Emma by Jane Austen from the library to read after seeing the intriguing movie.

Answer 3

I like to watch a film first then read the book to see how the film makers have totally changed the plot to fit 2hrs.
How to ruin the 'Hitch-Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy'!!! The BBC adaption was better. At least the film had the 'BBC' Marvin hidden away in it, I spotted. :) All the good bits were edited out. This could have been done as a sensible series of the five novels. Idiots! Marvin's silly head made it a joke. Marvin to me is the BBC interpretation.

Never read Harry Potter, yet seen the films. I think that odd.
Think it has been that way as been with girls and clever to be as planned as the series is, lots of ideas from several sources. I might read it all in one go some day when finished.

Answer 4

I tend to see the filmed version of a novel after reading the written version. Often the film can be disappointing. Many of Stephen King's books don't translate well to film.

Answer 5

i would prefer to watch the film before reading the book. this is because in the past when i have read the book before the film i criticise the film from start to finish for not following the book and spend more time looking for differences than enjoying the movie

Answer 6

No.If you read the book you will mostly will not like the film much.The film may not be up to the mark.The simple reason is that the language of film is different from the language of the book.Many things in the written book cannot be shown in the same way as described in the book.In the book the characters mould /grow in your mind as you like it,in the film they grow on the screen according the imagination of the director.These may differ.

Answer 7

I would prefer reading the book first other than watching the movie. Mainly because there are a lot of things left out of a book when the movie is maid for example in Stephen King's Misery the Book reads that she chopped off the writers leg at the knees, where as in the movie she only breaks them

Answer 8

I never watch film versions of novels I love.

Answer 9

I believe you - the e book over the action picture. i hit upon that no longer each thing is contained in the action picture, and that i comprehend that it would want to be uninteresting to contain each of the descriptive aspects of a tale, or the position there are extracts the position the author explains something and there is not any longer as a lot action or communicate. also, as you're saying, we are observing somebody else's point of view - in many situations a minimum of three: the producer, director and screenwriter who come to a decision what scenes will charm to audiences and keep on the plot. a minimum of with examining the books, i visit imagine the characters and surroundings as i imagine they must be (as an example, Dobby in "Harry Potter and the chamber of secrets and techniques" change into no longer something like I visualised and this positioned me off thoroughly) quite than to have it very nearly compelled upon me that how they have been filmed is the way that I might want to anticipate to visualize them.

Answer 10

I like seeing the movie after I read the novel. In the Harry Potter books, they leave a lot of stuff out in the movie that happened in the book.